Table 2.
Study | Publication year | Setting | Frequency of contact | Included peripherals | Intervention components | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Glucometer | Pedometer | BP monitor | Scale | Monitoring | Consultation | Counseling | Coaching | Education | Mentoring | Reminding | ||||
Abaza and Marschollek 42 | 2017 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Agarwal et al 43 | 2019 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Agarwal et al 44 | 2019 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Aguiar et al 45 | 2018 | Hospital | Once | x | ||||||||||
Akinci et al 46 | 2018 | University | x | |||||||||||
Al Omar et al 47 | 2020 | Primary | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Alanzi et al 48 | 2018 | Community | x | x | ||||||||||
Albikawi et al 49 | 2016 | Specialized | Once | x | ||||||||||
Alghafri et al 50 | 2018 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Ali et al 51 | 2016 | Specialized | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Ali et al 52 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Aliha et al 53 | 2013 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Alonso-Domínguez et al 54 | 2019 | Primary | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Alotaibi et al 55 | 2016 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Anderson et al 56 | 2009 | Community | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Anderson et al 57 | 2010 | Community | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Anderson-Loftin et al 58 | 2005 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Andreae et al 59 | 2020 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Anzaldo-Campos et al 60 | 2016 | Primary | x | x | x | |||||||||
Arora et al 61 | 2014 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Asante et al 62 | 2020 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Avdal et al 63 | 2011 | University | x | x | ||||||||||
Azizi et al 64 | 2016 | Specialized | x | x | ||||||||||
Benson et al 65 | 2018 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Blackberry et al 66 | 2013 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Bluml et al 67 | 2019 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Boels et al 12 | 2019 | Hospital | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Bogner et al 68 | 2012 | Primary | Twice | x | x | |||||||||
Bohingamu Mudiyanselage et al 69 | 2018 | Community | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Lashkari et al 70 | 2013 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Browning et al 71 | 2016 | Community | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Bujnowska-Fedak et al 72 | 2011 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Buysse et al 73 | 2019 | Hospital | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Capozza et al 74 | 2015 | Primary | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Carter et al 75 | 2011 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | x | x | x | ||||||
Castelnuovo et al 76 | 2011 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Chao et al 77 | 2019 | Hospital | x | |||||||||||
Chen et al 78 | 2008 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Chen et al 79 | 2018 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Chiu et al 80 | 2016 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Cho et al 81 | 2006 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Cho et al 82 | 2017 | Specialized | Weekly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Choe et al 83 | 2005 | University | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Choudhry et al 84 | 2018 | Primary | x | |||||||||||
Clark et al 85 | 2004 | Specialized | Fortnight | x | ||||||||||
Crowley et al 86 | 2013 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Crowley et al 87 | 2016 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Dale et al 88 | 2009 | Primary | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Dario et al 89 | 2017 | Tailored | x | x | ||||||||||
Davis et al 90 | 2010 | Community | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Del Prato et al 91 | 2012 | x | x | |||||||||||
Delahanty et al 92 | 2019 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Doupis et al 7 | 2019 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Dugas et al 93 | 2018 | Specialized | Daily | x | x | x | ||||||||
Duruturk and Özköslü 94 | 2019 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Döbler et al 95 | 2018 | Specialized | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Eakin et al 96 | 2013 | Primary | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Eakin et al 97 | 2014 | Primary | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Egede et al 98 | 2017 | Community | Weekly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Egede et al 99 | 2018 | Community | ||||||||||||
Estey et al 100 | 1990 | University | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Faridi et al 101 | 2008 | Community | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Farsaei et al 102 | 2011 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Fernandes et al 103 | 2016 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Fortmann et al 104 | 2017 | Community | Daily | x | x | x | ||||||||
Fottrell et al 105 | 2019 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Fountoulakis et al 106 | 2015 | Hospital | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Franc et al 107 | 2020 | Primary | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Franciosi et al 108 | 2011 | Specialized | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Frosch et al 109 | 2011 | Primary | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
García et al 110 | 2015 | Community | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Garg et al 111 | 2017 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Gagliardino et al 112 | 2013 | Specialized | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
Wasif Gillani 113 | 2016 | Hospital | Twice | x | x | |||||||||
Gimbel et al 114 | 2020 | Primary | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Glasgow et al 115 | 2006 | Primary care | Twice | x | ||||||||||
Glasgow et al 116 | 2006 | Twice | x | |||||||||||
Glasgow and Toobert 117 | 2000 | Specialized | Fortnight | x | ||||||||||
Glasgow et al 118 | 2002 | Specialized | Fortnight | x | ||||||||||
Glasgow et al 119 | 2005 | Primary care | x | |||||||||||
Goodarzi et al 120 | 2012 | Tailored | x | |||||||||||
Goodarzi et al 121 | 2018 | University | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Graziano and Gross 122 | 2009 | Cross-sectional | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Griffin et al 123 | 2014 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Gupta et al 124 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Haider et al 125 | 2019 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Hansen et al 126 | 2017 | Hospital | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Hare et al 127 | 2011 | Hospital | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
Hee-Sung 128 | 2007 | Hospital | Monthly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Heisler et al 129 | 2019 | Hospital | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Hidrus et al 130 | 2020 | Hospital | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Hokanson et al 131 | 2006 | Specialized | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
Holbrook et al 132 | 2009 | Primary | x | |||||||||||
Holmen et al 133 | 2014 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Hordern et al 134 | 2009 | Hospital | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Huang et al 135 | 2019 | Specialized | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Huizinga et al 136 | 2010 | University | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Hunt et al 137 | 2014 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Iljaž et al 138 | 2017 | Primary | Tailored | x | x | x | ||||||||
Islam et al 139 | 2019 | Hospital | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Jahangard-Rafsanjani et al 140 | 2015 | Community | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Jain et al 141 | 2018 | Community | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Jarab et al 142 | 2012 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Jennings et al 143 | 2014 | x | ||||||||||||
Jeong et al 144 | 2018 | Hospital | Twice | x | x | x | ||||||||
Jiwani et al 145 | 2020 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Kardas et al 146 | 2016 | Primary | x | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Kassavou et al 147 | 2020 | Primary | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Kempf et al 148 | 2017 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Keogh et al 149 | 2011 | Specialized | Once | x | ||||||||||
Kim and Utz 150 | 2019 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim 151 | 2007 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim and Jeong 152 | 2007 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim and Song 153 | 2008 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim and Kim 154 | 2008 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim and Oh 155 | 2003 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim et al 156 | 2005 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Kim and Kang 157 | 2006 | Hospital | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
Kim et al 158 | 2009 | Community | Monthly | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Kim et al 159 | 2010 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | x | ||||||||
Kim et al 160 | 2015 | Hospital | x | |||||||||||
Kim et al 161 | 2016 | Hospital | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
King et al 162 | 2006 | Primary | Twice | x | ||||||||||
Kirkman et al 163 | 1994 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Kleinman et al 164 | 2017 | Specialized | x | x | ||||||||||
Krein et al 165 | 2004 | Specialized | x | |||||||||||
Ku et al 166 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Kusnanto et al 167 | 2019 | Primary | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Kwon et al 168 | 2004 | Hospital | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Lauffenburger et al 169 | 2019 | Weekly | x | x | ||||||||||
Lazo-Porras et al 170 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Lee et al 171 | 2017 | Community | x | x | x | x | ||||||||
Lee et al 172 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Lee et al 173 | 2019 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Li et al 174 | 2016 | Hospital | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Liebreich et al 175 | 2009 | Weekly | x | x | ||||||||||
Lim et al 176 | 2011 | Hospital | x | x | ||||||||||
Lim et al 177 | 2016 | Hospital | x | x | x | |||||||||
Lorig et al 178 | 2010 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Lujan et al 179 | 2007 | Community | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Luley et al 180 | 2011 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Lutes et al 181 | 2017 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Lynch et al 182 | 2014 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
MacPhail et al 183 | 2014 | Primary | Twice | x | ||||||||||
Marios et al 184 | 2012 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Maslakpak et al 185 | 2017 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Mayberry et al 186 | 2020 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
McEwen et al 187 | 2017 | Community | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
McKay et al 188 | 2001 | Weekly | x | x | ||||||||||
McKay et al 189 | 2002 | Primary | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
McKee et al 190 | 2011 | Community | x | x | x | x | ||||||||
McMahon et al 191 | 2012 | Tailored | x | x | x | |||||||||
Mease 192 | 2000 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Mons et al 193 | 2013 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Moriyama et al 194 | 2009 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Mwangi et al 195 | 2020 | Hospital | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Namjoo Nasab et al 196 | 2017 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Nesari et al 197 | 2010 | Specialized | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Nicolucci et al 198 | 2015 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | x | x | x | ||||||
Niswender et al 199 | 2014 | Cross-sectional | Fortnight | x | ||||||||||
O’Neil et al 200 | 2016 | University | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Odegard and Christensen 201 | 2012 | Community | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Odnoletkova et al 202 | 2016 | Fortnight | x | |||||||||||
Oh et al 203 | 2003 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Orsama et al 204 | 2013 | Community | Tailored | x | x | x | x | x | ||||||
Owolabi et al 205 | 2019 | Primary | Daily | x | x | x | ||||||||
Parsons et al 206 | 2019 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Patja et al 207 | 2012 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Peasah et al 208 | 2019 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Peimani et al 209 | 2016 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Piette et al 210 | 2011 | Community | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Plotnikoff et al 211 | 2013 | Community | Tailored | x | ||||||||||
Presley et al 212 | 2020 | Community | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Quinn et al 213 | 2017 | Community | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Quinn et al 214 | 2011 | Community | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Raj and Mathews 215 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Ralston et al 216 | 2009 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Ramadas et al 217 | 2018 | Hospital | x | x | ||||||||||
Rasmussen et al 218 | 2016 | Specialized | x | |||||||||||
Rodríguez-Idígoras et al 219 | 2009 | Community | Tailored | x | x | |||||||||
Ruggiero et al 220 | 2014 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Sacco et al 221 | 2009 | University | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Sacco et al 222 | 2012 | University | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Samuel-Hodge et al 223 | 2009 | Community | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Sarayani et al 224 | 2018 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Saslow et al 225 | 2020 | University | Daily | x | ||||||||||
Sazlina et al 226 | 2015 | Primary | x | x | ||||||||||
Schillinger et al 227 | 2009 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Shahid et al 228 | 2015 | Specialized | Weekly | x | x | x | ||||||||
Shahsavari and Bakhshandeh Bavarsad 229 | 2020 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Shetty et al 230 | 2011 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Shreck et al 231 | 2014 | Fortnight | x | |||||||||||
Sigurdardottir et al 232 | 2009 | Specialized | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Skelly et al 233 | 2009 | Cross-sectional | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Sone et al 234 | 2002 | Specialized | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Sone et al 235 | 2010 | Specialized | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Song and Kim 236 | 2009 | Specialized | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Spencer et al 237 | 2018 | Community | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Steventon et al 238 | 2014 | Cross-sectional | Daily | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Sun et al 239 | 2019 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Sunil Kumar et al 240 | 2020 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | x | ||||||||
Takenga et al 241 | 2014 | Hospital | x | |||||||||||
Tamban et al 242 | 2013 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Tan et al 243 | 2018 | Primary | Fortnight | x | ||||||||||
Tang et al 244 | 2013 | x | x | x | ||||||||||
Teston et al 245 | 2017 | Fortnight | x | |||||||||||
Thom et al 246 | 2013 | Community | Fortnight | x | x | |||||||||
Torbjørnsen et al 247 | 2014 | Monthly | x | x | ||||||||||
Tu et al 248 | 1993 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Van Dyck et al 249 | 2013 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Van Dyck et al 250 | 2011 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Van Vugt et al 251 | 2016 | Primary | x | x | ||||||||||
Varney et al 252 | 2014 | Hospital | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Vaughan et al 253 | 2020 | Primary | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Vervloet et al 254 | 2014 | x | ||||||||||||
Vinithia et al 255 | 2019 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Von Storch et al 256 | 2019 | Weekly | x | x | x | |||||||||
Wakefield et al 257 | 2011 | Primary | Daily | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Wakefield et al 258 | 2012 | Primary | Daily | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Wakefield et al 259 | 2014 | University | Tailored | x | x | x | ||||||||
Waki et al 260 | 2014 | University | Tailored | x | x | x | x | x | ||||||
Walker et al 261 | 2011 | Specialized | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Wang et al 262 | 2020 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Wang et al 263 | 2019 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Wang et al 264 | 2017 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Warren et al 265 | 2018 | Primary | Daily | x | x | x | x | |||||||
Weinberger et al 266 | 1995 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Whittemore et al 267 | 2004 | Specialized | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Wichit et al 268 | 2017 | Hospital | Once | x | x | |||||||||
Wild et al 269 | 2016 | Primary | x | x | x | x | ||||||||
Williams et al 270 | 2012 | Hospital | Weekly | x | ||||||||||
Williams et al 271 | 2017 | Primary | Monthly | x | ||||||||||
Wolever et al 272 | 2010 | Weekly | x | |||||||||||
Wolf et al 273 | 2004 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Wu et al 274 | 2017 | University | Once | x | x | |||||||||
Yang et al 275 | 2020 | Primary | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Yasmin et al 276 | 2020 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | x | ||||||||
Yoo et al 277 | 2009 | University | Tailored | x | x | x | x | x | ||||||
Yoon and Kim 278 | 2008 | Hospital | Weekly | x | x | |||||||||
Young et al 279 | 2005 | Primary | Monthly | x | x | |||||||||
Yu et al 280 | 2019 | Hospital | Daily | x | x | |||||||||
Zamanzadeh et al 281 | 2017 | Daily | x | |||||||||||
Zhou et al 282 | 2014 | Hospital | Fortnight | x | x | x | x | x |
Abbreviation: BP, blood pressure.