Skip to main content
. 2023 May 22;11:e15336. doi: 10.7717/peerj.15336

Table 2. Cases of discrepancies between morphological and molecular-based identifications.

Discrepancy Morphotype Nr. of sequences Morphological ID of specimen BIN Molecular ID linked to BIN
Type 1 “Acricotopus lucens 2 Acricotopus lucens BOLD:AAG5487 Procladius crassinervis
“Chironomus” 1 Chironomus plumosus BOLD:ACT6966 Chironomus obtusidens
“Chironomus” 1 Chironomus prasinatus BOLD:AAU4046 Chironomus annularius
“Chironomus” 1 Chironomus sp. BOLD:ADF1214 Benthalia carbonaria
“Dicrotendipes” 1 Dicrotendipes tritomus BOLD:AAU1021 Dicrotendipes nervosus
“Endochironomus” 2 Endochironomus albipennis BOLD:AAW5643 Endochironomus tendens
“Endochironomus” 1 Endochironomus stackelbergi BOLD:AAW5643 Endochironomus tendens
“Glyptotendipes” 1 Glyptotendipes cauliginellus BOLD:ACD4470 Glyptotendipes pallens
“Glyptotendipes” 1 Glyptotendipes glaucus BOLD:ACD4470 Glyptotendipes pallens
“Glyptotendipes” 1 Glyptotendipes glaucus BOLD:AAC0597 Glyptotendipes paripes
“Parachironomus” 3 Parachironomus gracilior BOLD:ACY5073 Parachironomus monochromus
“Paratanytarsus/Rheotanytarsus” 1 Paratanytarsus laetipes BOLD:AAI6018 Cricotopus bicinctus
“Procladius ferrugineus 2 Procladius ferrugineus BOLD:AAG5487 Procladius crassinervis
“Procladius pectinatus 1 Procladius pectinatus BOLD:ACW5385 Procladius culiciformis
“Pseudosmittia obtusa 1 Pseudosmittia obtusa BOLD:ACP4407 Pseudosmittia trilobata
“Smittia aterrima” 2 Smittia aterrima BOLD:AAN5358 Smittia stercoraria
“Tanypus punctipennis” 1 Tanypus punctipennis BOLD:ADJ7832 Tanypus kraatzi
“Tanytarsus” 1 Tanytarsus reei BOLD:ACF7553 Tanytarsus heusdensis
“Tanytarsus” 2 Tanytarsus dispar BOLD:ACG9929 Tanytarsus medius
“Xenopelopia nigricans” 1 Xenopelopia nigricans BOLD:ADJ7832 Tanypus kraatzi
Type 2 “Ablabesmyia phatta” 1 Ablabesmyia phatta BOLD:ACK3818 Ablabesmyia sp. 2ES
“Chironomidae” 12 Chironomidae sp. BOLD:AAC0597 Glyptotendipes paripes
“Cladopelma/Cryptochironomus/Harnischia” 1 Cladopelma sp. BOLD:AAV3586 Cladopelma viridulum
“Cladopelma/Cryptochironomus/Harnischia” 1 Cladopelma sp. BOLD:AAV8096 Cladopelma virescens
“Endochironomus” 9 Endochironomus sp. BOLD:AAW5643 Endochironomus tendens
“Glyptotendipes” 1 Glyptotendipes sp. BOLD:ACD4470 Glyptotendipes pallenses
“Psectrocladius” 1 Psectrocladius sp. BOLD:AAU0273 Psectrocladius limbatellus
“Smittia terrestris” 2 Smittia terrestris BOLD:ACP4736 Interim species Smittia sp. 8ES
“Smittia terrestris” 7 Smittia terrestris BOLD:ACW5117 Interim species Smittia sp. 14ES
“Thienemanniella” 1 Thienemanniella vittata BOLD:AAV3048 Interim species Thienemanniella sp. 3TE
Type 3 “Acricotopus lucens” 1 Acricotopus lucens BOLD:AEO5089 No public data
“Chironomus” 6 Chironomus curabilis BOLD:ACD8415 Chironomus curabilis/nuditarsis
“Cricotopus” 2 Cricotopus sp. BOLD:AEO5089 No public data
“Cricotopus” 3 Cricotopus sylvestris BOLD:AAA5299 Cricotopus sylvestris/glacialis
“Cricotopus” 1 Cricotopus tricinctus BOLD:AEG4456 Cricotopus tricinctus/sylvestris/trifasciatus
“Cricotopus” 9 Cricotopus sylvestris BOLD:AAA5299 Cricotopus sylvestris/glacialis
“Glyptotendipes” 4 Glyptotendipes cauliginellus BOLD:AAF8348 Glyptotendipes cauliginellus/lobiferus
“Metriocnemus” 1 Metriocnemus sp. BOLD:ADV3586 No public data
“Microtendipes chloris” 5 Microtendipes chloris BOLD:ACY5270 Microtendipes pedellus/chloris
“Parachironomus” 1 Parachironomus sp. BOLD:ADV3586 No public data
“Procladius crassinervis” 4 Procladius crassinervis BOLD:ACB6320 Procladius sp.
Psectrocladius oxyura 1 Psectrocladius oxyura BOLD:AEO4348 No public data
“Tanytarsus usmaensis” 2 Tanytarsus usmaensis BOLD:AEO0788 No public data

Note:

Morphotypes, number of sequences, and identifications that were involved in discrepant results, namely complete incongruences in identification across methods (type 1), molecular methods provided more species-level information than morphology (type 2), and Morphology provided more species-level information while molecular methods provided inconclusive or no identification at all (type 3).