Table 1.
Characteristics of the studies.
Author, Reference, Country | Aims | Participants | Modalities | Evaluation Techniques | Results | Quality Score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Aitchison et al. [59] United Kingdom |
Explore the experiences of social support in elite British para-swimmers and the influence on their wellbeing and performance |
N = 9 British para-swimmers (3 male, 5 female, mean age 24.9 years). Disabilities: physical, visual and intellectual disabilities |
Swimming | Semistructured interviews with duration ranging from 48 to 88 min (mean ± SD length 61 ± 15.3 min) | Social support in British para-swimmers is important for performance and wellbeing, especially a strong coach–athlete relationship, motivational and supportive teammates. | Fair |
Atkinson and Martin [60] U.S.A. |
Understanding if grit, hardiness, resilience and the added variable of athlete social support would predict life satisfaction and sport engagement in wheelchair rugby athletes |
N = 87 adult athletes (80 males and 7 females). 35 in-person and 52 online. M age = 35.94 years, SD = 9.26) Disabilities: amputation (n = 6), spinal cord injury (n = 60), cerebral palsy (n = 9), other (n = 2). |
Wheelchair rugby | Connor–Davidson Resilience Scales revised Norwegian Hardiness scale Satisfaction with Life Scale. 16-item Athlete Engagement Questionnaire 22-item Athletes’ Received Social Support Questionnaire |
The resilience predicted 32% of the variance in life satisfaction and was the only significant predictor of life satisfaction. Grit, social support, resilience and hardiness were all significant predictors. |
Good |
Cardoso and Sacomori [61] Brazil |
Examine resilience in the specific subgroupof Brazilian competitive athletes with physical disabilities. Test the validity of the Wagnild and Young (1993) Resilience Scale in Brazil for this population |
N = 136 athletes Aged 18 or over with Disabilities: physical |
Track and field, table tennis, swimming, weightlifting, basketball, rowing and tennis. |
Semistructured interviews The questionnaire consists of 25 items |
Participants were observed to have achieved higher resilience scores, while those with cerebral palsy obtained the lowest and those with amputations or polio obtained intermediate scores. The participants in this research study displayed a significantly lower mean resilience than those reported in other studies with the general population. | Fair |
Cardoso et al. [62] Brazil |
Describe the importance of structural and human resources support for Brazilian Paralympic athletes |
N = 10 Paralympic athletes Athletics (7 males and 3 females) M age 28 ± 7.95. Swimming N = 10 (8 male and 2 female) M age = 22.50 ± 4.54 Disabilities: physical |
Athletics and swimming | Semistructured interview | The results show that structural support and human resources support are considered fundamental by the interviewed athletes. |
Poor |
Crawford, Burns and Fernie [63] United Kingdom |
Investigate the relationship between psychological resilience and vulnerability factors and involvement in the SO compared to being involved in sport not through the SO, and no sports activity |
N = 101 (44 female and 57 male) M age 35.1 (range 18–67) Disabilities: intellectual |
Athletics, football, judo, swimming, bowling and multiple sports | Demographic questionnaire Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence (WASI) Rosenberg Self-esteem Scale The Life Stress Inventory Social Support Self Report |
The results indicate that there is an association between involvement in the SO and reduced stress, increased quality of life and higher self-esteem. The hypothesis of increased social networks was not demonstrated. The findings provide further evidence of a positive association between sport involvement and increased psychological wellbeing, especially for those involved in the SO. |
Good |
Downie and Koestner [64] Canada |
Study 1 compared the relation between success in the Paralympics versus the Olympics and national subjective well-being and life expectancy. Study 2 conceptually replicated these results using the standings of national men’s and women’s soccer teams |
Olympics and Paralympics athletes | Olympics and Paralympics modalities (not specified) Soccer |
Olympic and Paralympic Performance. Happiness. Data were taken from the World Database of Happiness |
Study 1—There were mean differences in happiness for those countries that had a Paralympics team compared to those that did not. This suggests that even though countries without a Paralympics team were no less wealthy, or happy, their physical well-being was reduced. Study 2—Countries with a female soccer team were happier. |
Poor |
Dursun et al. [65] Turkey |
Assess the effects of ice skating on the psychological well-being, self-concept and sleep quality of children with hearing or visual impairments |
N = 40 students (20 visually impaired and 20 hearing impaired) Aged 8–16 Disabilities: visual and deaf |
Ice skating | A self-report form of the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) The Piers–Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale (PHCSCS) Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) |
There was a significant improvement in self-concept, behavioural and emotional problems and sleep quality (p < 0.05 for each) in of the children with hearing impairment. Although the sleep quality (p = 0.019) and emotional problem scores (p ¼ 0.000) of the visually impaired children improved, self-concept, peer relations and hyperactivity scores of these children worsened (p50.05 for each). |
Fair |
Fiorilli et al. [66] Italia |
To examine the perception of well-being, social integration and emotional problems of Down Syndrome (DS) subjects and to investigate whether parents and their children with Down Syndrome have the same opinion on the problems caused by DS |
N = 93 participants with DS 58 swimmers (aged 16.31 ± 1.55), 35 DS sedentary subjects (aged 16.06 ± 1.39), and their parents (n = 93). Disabilities: Down Syndrome |
Swimming | 2 questionnaires (SDQ) were individually administered: self-reported version (SDQ-SR), completed by the DS participants, and the parental version (SDQ-P), completed by their parents |
Results showed significant differences between sportive vs. non-sportive groups in the overall domain scores, with better results for the sportive group. Parents of DS non-sportive participants underestimated their children’s problems in 6 of the 8 domains. The results validate the hypothesis that foresees a positive relation between well-being perception and sport activity and competitions in individuals with MR, such as DS. |
Good |
Hamdani et al. [67] Canada |
To understand the state of perceived wellness and wellness-promoting behaviours of children and youth with IDD from multi-stakeholder perspectives |
N = 35 in-person surveys of athletes N = 352 online surveys of caregivers (n = 240) and coaches (n = 112) Disabilities: intellectual |
Special Olympics | A cross-sectional Likert survey methodology | Athletes, caregivers and coaches generally agreed rather than disagreed with wellness statements, with the exception of coaches’ responses regarding healthy nutrition. Athletes agreed more than caregivers and coaches that they engaged in some wellness-promoting behaviours (i.e., calming oneself down, participating in their communities). |
Fair |
Haslett, Fitzpatrick and Breslin [68] Ireland |
To interpret participation in wheelchair rugby through the conceptual lens of the SRM |
N = 10 male athletes from three clubs (M age = 33.1 years, age range: 22–53 years). | Wheelchair Rugby | A semistructured interview guide was developed based on the components of the SRM | The results indicate that in disability sport participation, the experience of social oppression, inequality and cultural stereotypes of disability can be synonymous with the personal experience of physical impairment. |
Poor |
Kokun et al. [69] Ukraine |
To determine the influence of sports on Paralympic athletes’ personal development |
N = 106 Paralympic and Defilimnical (Age 16–53, 84 men and 22 women) N = 191 students (Age 17–25, 91 without health problems, 98 with disabilities not engaged in sports) Disabilities: physical and deaf |
Paralympic sports | The Ryff Scales of Psychological Well-Being and S. Maddi’s Personal Hardiness test. | Paralympic athletes achieve an optimal level of psychological well-being and a significant increase in all psychological hardiness components. | Fair |
Kokun, Serdiuk and Shamyco [70] Ukraine |
To investigate the personal characteristics supporting Paralympic athletes’ self-realization in sports. |
N = 106 Paralympic and Defilimnical in different sports (Age 16–53, 84 men and 22 women) Disabilities: physical and deaf |
Paralympic sports (football, fencing, powerlifting, sitting volleyball, judo, canoeing in pairs, swimming) |
Self-efficacy scale of R. Schwarzer and M. Yerusalem; Ryff’s Scales of Psychological Well-Being; S. Maddi’s Personal Hardiness test (adapted by D. Leont’ev); the modified techniques of scaled self-estimation; The Self-Organization Questionnaire |
The most important personal characteristic supporting Paralympic athletes’ self-realization in sports is their psychological hardiness, since all four of its indicators have sufficiently close correlations with three of the four self-realization indicators—“Satisfaction with own sports career”, “Fastness of sportive goal setting after achievement of a previous one” and “Reaching of top-achievements in sports”. Paralympic athletes’ rapidity in sportive goal setting after achievement of a previous one is significantly related to all ten psychological well-being scales, and their clarity of perception of own future in sports correlates with five scales. |
Fair |
Macdougall et al. [71] Australia |
Explore well-being in para-athletes in a way that is consistent with theoretical perspectives |
N = 23 para-athletes (10 female and 13 male) M age = 28.5 years, age range = 16–53 years) Disabilities: physical |
Athletics, boccia, canoe slalom, cycling, swimming, table tennis, triathlon, wheelchair basketball, wheelchair rugby | Semistructured interviews | The well-being needs and strengths of para-athletes differed across gender, sport, level of competition and nature of impairment. Well-being strengths were perceived to increase as athletes increased their level of competition, and included personal growth, optimism, strong social support networks and contributing to multiple communities. |
Poor |
Machida, Irwin and Fetz [47] U.S.A. |
Examine the resilience process of sport participants with acquired spinal cord injury, and the role of sport participation in the resilience process |
N = 12 men with aged 21 to 41 years Disabilities: physical |
Wheelchair rugby | Semistructured interviews | The development of resilience is a multifactorial process involving pre-existing factors and pre-adversity experiences, disturbance/disturbing emotions, various types and sources of social support, special opportunities and experiences, various behavioural and cognitive coping strategies, motivation to adapt to changes and learned attributes or gains from the resilience process. |
Poor |
Martin et al. [72] U.S.A. |
To predict both general and sport-specific quality of life using measures of grit, hardiness and resilience |
N = 75 (74 males and 1 female) M age = 37.0 years, SD = 11.01 Disabilities: physical |
Wheelchair basketball | 8-question Short Grit Scale Connor–Davidson Resilience Scales revised Norwegian hardiness scale (Dispositional Resilience Scale Satisfaction with Life Scale 16-item Athlete Engagement Questionnaire |
Hardiness and resilience combined to predict 26% of the variance in life satisfaction, whereas grit was not a significant predictor. Athletes higher in both resilience and hardiness expressed greater life satisfaction compared with athletes lower in hardiness and resilience. |
Good |
Martin et al. [73] U.S.A. |
Determine if grit, hardiness and resilience predicted life satisfaction and sport engagement in parasport athletes |
N = 40 (22 ice hockey athletes and 18 wheelchair rugby) (M age = 32.0; SD = 8.6) Disabilities: physical |
Ice hockey, wheelchair rugby |
Short Grit Scale (Grit-S)10-item Connor–Davidson Resilience Scale (10- item CD-RISC) Norwegian hardiness scale (Dispositional Resilience Scale 15 (DSR-15) Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS) 16 item Athlete Engagement Questionnaire (AEQ) |
Hardiness and resilience are important predictors of life satisfaction, with grit being irrelevant, and resilience and grit are important predictors of sport engagement. Overall resilience appears to be the most critical predictor for both outcomes across the three studies. |
Good |
Mira et al. [74] Portugal |
Characterizing subjective well-being, resilience and social influence |
N = 31 of the 33 athletes of the Portuguese Paralympic team M age = 34.45 ± 11.7 years (21 men and 10 women) Disabilities: physical |
Multiple sports | Social support perceived by athletes with disabilities, a scale based on the recommendations of Jago et al. Subjective well-being was assessed through Satisfaction with Life Scale Positive and negative affect were evaluated through PANAS—The Positive and Negative Affect Schedule Brief Resilience Scale (BRS) |
Athletes perceive a positive affect superior to negative affect. Regarding social support, the perception of support by the coach is the one with the highest value. The bivariate correlation was observed between life satisfaction and positive affect (medium), between positive affect with social support from parents (high) and between positive affect with social support from friends (medium). Resilience displayed a negative and significant association with the negative affect (high). |
Good |
Monton et al. [75] Canada |
Explores the role of sport–life balance and well-being on athletic performance. |
N = 47 Olympic athletes N = 14 Paralympic athletes N = 11 not specified (2 male, 40 female and 10 athletes that did not specify) Disabilities: physical |
Multiple sports | Mixed-methods research design consisting of an online survey and a series of semistructured, follow-up interviews. |
Overwhelmingly, athletes felt they received the most support from family and friends. These results exemplify the importance of athletes’ external support systems. | Poor |
Mudjianto, Widya and Ubad [76] Indonesia |
Determine the quality of life of Paralympic athletes who are members in West Java Peparnas Pelatda 2016 | Handicapped/disabled athletes from Pelatda West Java | Not specified | Questionnaire WHOQOL-BREF | From the results of the analysis and calculation of the data obtained, the four domains of physical health, psychological well-being, social relationships and the relationship with the environment showed a good average range. | Poor |
Porto, Cardoso and Sacomori [77] Chile |
To analyse the association of team sports practice and physical and psychological factors with sexual adjustment in men with paraplegia |
N = 60 men (30 wheelchair basketball and/or handball athletes and 30 non-athletes) Disabilities: physical |
Wheelchair basketball and/or handball athletes | The Resilience Scale | Resilience was correlated with and predictive of sexual adjustment. | Good |
Powell and Myers [78] United Kingdom |
Understand the lived experiences of mentally tough Paralympians, aiming to conceptualize MT in a Paralympic context and investigate its development |
N = 10 Team Great Britain Paralympic athletes (9 male and 1 female M age = 27.9, SD = 7.1) Disabilities: physical |
Multiple sports | Semistructured interview | The development of MT requires a series of formative experiences, combined with support and coping resources. Athletes in general would benefit from exposure to highly demanding situations in a supportive environment to develop mentally tough characteristics and behaviours and to develop personalized cognitive strategies. |
Poor |
Puce et al. [79] Italy |
Investigate the role of competitive sport practice in enhancing the self-perceived psychophysical well-being of some select participants |
N = 100 Paralympic athletes N = 100 affected by impairment who do not practice competitive sport Disabilities: physical |
Swimming | Psychological General Well-Being Index and the Short Form indices | Possible positive psychophysical benefits of competitive sport practice for young people affected by physical or intellectual impairment. |
Poor |
Richardson et al. [80] United Kingdom |
To assess the psychosocial impact of participating in sport at an individual level and the impact of participating in sport in challenging cultural perceptions of disability |
N = 16 (14 males and 2 females) M age 29 years (age range 18–40) Disabilities: physical |
Wheelchair tennis | Semistructured interview | Wheelchair tennis players perceived that their participation in sport enhanced their psychosocial well-being. Three broad themes emerged from analysis of the interviews: (1) developed transferrable skills, (2) perceived personal growth and (3) benefits of an athletic identity. | Good |
Saphiro and Malone [81] U.S.A. |
Examined the relationship between athlete and parent perceptions of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) and the relationship between the athletes’ perceived HRQoL and subjective exercise evaluations |
N = 70 athletes (47 males and 23 females) (M age = 15, SD = 2.92) Disabilities: physical |
Swimming (n 5 3), wheelchair basketball (n 5 23), wheelchair handball (n 5 32), and a weekend multisports program (n 5 12 |
Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory (PedsQL) Subjective Exercise Experiences Scale (SEES) |
Athletes with disabilities reported higher perceptions of HRQoL than their parents reported for them on physical, emotional and social functioning subscales with moderate to high effect sizes. Positive well-being subscale from the SEES was significantly related to overall HRQoL and was a significant predictor of overall HRQoL. | Good |
Shapiro and Martin [82] U.S.A. |
Examine athletic identity, affect and peer relations of youth athletes with physical disabilities and selected relationships among these variables |
N = 36 (27 males and 9 females) M age = 16 Disabilities: physical |
Swimming, wheelchair basketball, wheelchair handball, multisport program | Private–Public Athletic Identity Scale The Positive and Negative Affect Schedule The Peer Relations Scale |
Participants reported stronger private athletic identity individual item scores compared with public athletic identity and expressed high positive affect and low negative affect. They also expressed strong peer relations. A significant relationship between positive affect and peer relations was found. | Good |
Sikorska and Gerc [7] Poland |
To describe selected aspects of a good life in Polish Paralympic athletes in light of positive psychology |
N =30 disabled athletes (M = 26.5 years of age) N control group = 30 healthy young adults (M = 25.9 years of age) Disabilities: physical |
Skiing, cycling, swimming, fencing, basketball | The You and Your Life Questionnaire The Resilience Scale for Adults by Friborg et al. (RSA) The Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS) Personal Values List (LWO) |
A statistically relevant difference between the two groups can be identified with regard to resilience, concerning the structured style factor and with regards to courage in the level of the endurance factor. Disabled athletes choose the following as highly assessed values: being useful, courage and firmness. |
Fair |
Swason, Colwell and Zhao [83] U.S.A. |
This study explored relationships among four sources of motivation and six forms of social support |
N = 19 wheelchair athletes, (33 male and 60 female) M age = 19.79, SD = 4.93 Disabilities: physical |
Wheelchair basketball | Survey | Importance of social support types differed according to skill level, playing level, years played and future playing intentions. | Good |