Table 1.
This table organizes the main experimental works in which a “tumor reversion process” has been observed or induced. Each work is presented highlighting the tumor model, the experimental methodology, the results and some relevant comments.
Tumor Model | Experimental Methodology | Results | Comments | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ovarian teratocarcinoma | Clinical observation | Spontaneous regression, differentiation of cancer cells into normal tissue | Askanazy, 1907 [1] | |
Plant teratoma clonal cells | Succession of grafts on healthy tobacco plant | Disappearance of the teratoma and plant generation with seeds capable of giving life to a new plant | The results led the author to introduce the concept of pluripotentiality of cancer cells | Braun, 1959 [16] |
Murine embryonic tumor cells | Transplantation on mice | Differentiation of cells | Hypothesis on the role of the tissue context in determining the fate of cancer cells | Pierce, 1961 [4] |
Hamster sarcoma cells (induced by Rous sarcoma virus) | Succession of cell cultures and re-platings | Transformation of 19% of cells, which return to orienting themselves in an orderly manner, as in healthy tissues | The author uses the term “reversion” to describe results | Macpherson, 1965 [17] |
Murine testicular teratocarcinoma cells (black mice) | Injection into murine blastocyst implanted in albino female mice | Development of healthy mice | One of the mice had black tufts, characteristic traits of the genome of teratocarcinoma cells | Brinster, 1974 [5] |
Embryonic carcinoma cells from black mice | Blastocyst injection implanted in brown female mice | Normal fetal development; normal newborn mice feature hybrid traits between black and brown mice | Authors use the term “reversion” to describe their findings | Mintz and Illmensee, 1975 [6] |
Lucke renal tumor cells (tumor of viral origin) | Planting on regenerative salamander limbs | Stopping of tumor growth and subsequent differentiation of cells | Failed to determine whether the differentiated cells came from cancer cells or healthy tissue | Rose and Wa llingford, 1948 [18,19] |
Spontaneous tumors in animals | Observations on the rate of onset | Reduced occurrence of tumors in animals with high regenerative capacities | Gersch, 1951 [20] |
|
Triton-induced epithelial tumors | Monitoring the spontaneous evolution of tumors | Tendency to tumor regression in anatomical areas with high regenerative potential | Results confirmed by histological analysis | Seilern-Aspangand Kratochwil, 1962 [21] |
Liver cancer cells (marked with dye) | Injected into liver tissue | Reduction of malignancy and, in some cases, differentiation of cancer cells | Use of the term “partial reversion” to describe the phenotypic change of cells | Coleman, 1993 [22] |
Neuroblastoma cells | Injected into 8 ½ day old murine blastocyst | Differentiation of tumor cells | Podesta, 1984 [23] | |
Leukemia cells | Injected into 10-day-old murine blastocyst | Correct hematopoietic maturation | Gootwine, 1982 [24] |
|
Rous sarcoma virus | Injected into chicken embryos | No tumor development | If the virus is injected into adult chickens, then sarcoma develops | Dolberg and Bissell, 1984 [7] |
Mouse melanoma cells | Implanted into embryos in murine uterus | Cell differentiation and normal embryonic development | Differentiation occurs when cells are implanted into a 14-day embryo | Gerschenson, 1986 [9] |
Murine breast adenocarcinoma cells | Exposure to diffusible substances of murine embryonic mesenchyme | Differentiation of tumor cells | DeCosse, 1973 [25] |
|
Primary murine lung cancer | Administration (in vivo) of homogenates of pregnant murine uteri | Suppression of tumor development | Biava, 1988 [26] |
|
Glioblastoma, melanoma, renal adenocarcinoma, breast cancer, and lymphoblastic leukemia cells | Exposure to embryonic extracts of zebrafish taken before gastrulation | Reduction of cell proliferation rates | Biava, 2001; 2002 [27,28] |
|
Human melanoma cells | Implanted in zebrafish embryos in the early stages of development | Suppression of malignant tumor phenotype and birth of healthy fish | Lee, Hendrix, 2005 [10] |
|
Leukemia cells | Retinoic acid administration | Differentiation of leukemia cells into granulocytes, subsequently digested by macrophages | Today, acute promyelocytic leukemia is treated in most cases with differential treatments based on retinoic acid | Breitman, 1980 [29] |
Various types of human tumors | Clinical remarks | Spontaneous regressions of tumors | Several cases of spontaneous regression of tumors have been analyzed, confirmed, and classified | Rohdenburg, 1918; Everson and Cole, 1966; Challis and Stam 1990; O’Regan and Hirshberg, 1993; Papac, 1998 [30,31,32,33,34] |
Advanced hepatocarcinoma (179 cases) | In vivo administration of extracts of zebrafish embryos | 20% of cancer regressions, of which 2.5% total stabilization progression in 16% of cases | Partial or complete disappearance of liver cancer in terminally ill patients | Livraghi, 2005 [35] |
Melanoma cells and breast cancer cells | Exposed to embryonic stem cell factors | Reversal of the malignant phenotype and activation of apoptotic processes (nodal signal inhibition was also observed) | If cells are exposed to factors extracted from umbilical cord and bone marrow stem cells, then no phenotypic reversion is observed | Henrix, 2007; Postovit, 2008 [36,37] |
Ovarian, prostate, and breast cancer cells | Microenvironmental exposure of human embryonic stem cells | Reversion of malignant phenotype block of cancer cells in phase G1 | These results led researchers to hypothesize an inhibitory action on the cell cycle by factors extracted from embryonic stem cells | Giuffrida, 2009 [38] |
Melanoma cells | Microenvironmental exposure of human embryonic stem cells | Reversion of malignant phenotype | The study identified some mRNAs involved in these cellular reprogramming processes. | Costa, 2009 [39] |
Breast cancer cells | Exposure to salamander, frog, and mouse embryonic cell extracts | Stable reversal of malignant phenotype (confirmed with subsequent implantation of reprogrammed cells in immunosuppressed mice) | Re-expression of some cancer suppressor genes has been observed; mouse embryonic cells did not give results | Allegrucci, 2011 [40] |
Breast cancer cells | Exposure to embryonic extracts of zebrafish taken at different times of embryogenesis | Reduction of invasiveness, migration, and proliferation parameters; action on cytoskeleton and TCTP downregulation | An activation method of reversion was identified, implying the down-regulation of TCTP by exposing the cells to a specific embryonic microenvironment composition that corresponds to a specific phase of embryogenesis | Proietti and Bizzarri, 2019 [12] |