Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 24;13(5):733. doi: 10.3390/biom13050733

Table 1.

This table organizes the main experimental works in which a “tumor reversion process” has been observed or induced. Each work is presented highlighting the tumor model, the experimental methodology, the results and some relevant comments.

Tumor Model Experimental Methodology Results Comments Ref.
Ovarian teratocarcinoma Clinical observation Spontaneous regression, differentiation of cancer cells into normal tissue Askanazy, 1907 [1]
Plant teratoma clonal cells Succession of grafts on healthy tobacco plant Disappearance of the teratoma and plant generation with seeds capable of giving life to a new plant The results led the author to introduce the concept of pluripotentiality of cancer cells Braun, 1959 [16]
Murine embryonic tumor cells Transplantation on mice Differentiation of cells Hypothesis on the role of the tissue context in determining the fate of cancer cells Pierce, 1961
[4]
Hamster sarcoma cells (induced by Rous sarcoma virus) Succession of cell cultures and re-platings Transformation of 19% of cells, which return to orienting themselves in an orderly manner, as in healthy tissues The author uses the term “reversion” to describe results Macpherson, 1965 [17]
Murine testicular teratocarcinoma cells (black mice) Injection into murine blastocyst implanted in albino female mice Development of healthy mice One of the mice had black tufts, characteristic traits of the genome of teratocarcinoma cells Brinster, 1974
[5]
Embryonic carcinoma cells from black mice Blastocyst injection implanted in brown female mice Normal fetal development; normal newborn mice feature hybrid traits between black and brown mice Authors use the term “reversion” to describe their findings Mintz and Illmensee, 1975 [6]
Lucke renal tumor cells (tumor of viral origin) Planting on regenerative salamander limbs Stopping of tumor growth and subsequent differentiation of cells Failed to determine whether the differentiated cells came from cancer cells or healthy tissue Rose and Wa llingford, 1948 [18,19]
Spontaneous tumors in animals Observations on the rate of onset Reduced occurrence of tumors in animals with high regenerative capacities Gersch, 1951
[20]
Triton-induced epithelial tumors Monitoring the spontaneous evolution of tumors Tendency to tumor regression in anatomical areas with high regenerative potential Results confirmed by histological analysis Seilern-Aspangand Kratochwil, 1962 [21]
Liver cancer cells (marked with dye) Injected into liver tissue Reduction of malignancy and, in some cases, differentiation of cancer cells Use of the term “partial reversion” to describe the phenotypic change of cells Coleman, 1993 [22]
Neuroblastoma cells Injected into 8 ½ day old murine blastocyst Differentiation of tumor cells Podesta, 1984 [23]
Leukemia cells Injected into 10-day-old murine blastocyst Correct hematopoietic maturation Gootwine, 1982
[24]
Rous sarcoma virus Injected into chicken embryos No tumor development If the virus is injected into adult chickens, then sarcoma develops Dolberg and Bissell, 1984
[7]
Mouse melanoma cells Implanted into embryos in murine uterus Cell differentiation and normal embryonic development Differentiation occurs when cells are implanted into a 14-day embryo Gerschenson, 1986 [9]
Murine breast adenocarcinoma cells Exposure to diffusible substances of murine embryonic mesenchyme Differentiation of tumor cells DeCosse, 1973
[25]
Primary murine lung cancer Administration (in vivo) of homogenates of pregnant murine uteri Suppression of tumor development Biava, 1988
[26]
Glioblastoma, melanoma, renal adenocarcinoma, breast cancer, and lymphoblastic leukemia cells Exposure to embryonic extracts of zebrafish taken before gastrulation Reduction of cell proliferation rates Biava, 2001; 2002
[27,28]
Human melanoma cells Implanted in zebrafish embryos in the early stages of development Suppression of malignant tumor phenotype and birth of healthy fish Lee, Hendrix, 2005
[10]
Leukemia cells Retinoic acid administration Differentiation of leukemia cells into granulocytes, subsequently digested by macrophages Today, acute promyelocytic leukemia is treated in most cases with differential treatments based on retinoic acid Breitman, 1980
[29]
Various types of human tumors Clinical remarks Spontaneous regressions of tumors Several cases of spontaneous regression of tumors have been analyzed, confirmed, and classified Rohdenburg, 1918; Everson and Cole, 1966; Challis and Stam 1990; O’Regan and Hirshberg, 1993; Papac, 1998
[30,31,32,33,34]
Advanced hepatocarcinoma (179 cases) In vivo administration of extracts of zebrafish embryos 20% of cancer regressions, of which 2.5% total stabilization progression in 16% of cases Partial or complete disappearance of liver cancer in terminally ill patients Livraghi, 2005
[35]
Melanoma cells and breast cancer cells Exposed to embryonic stem cell factors Reversal of the malignant phenotype and activation of apoptotic processes (nodal signal inhibition was also observed) If cells are exposed to factors extracted from umbilical cord and bone marrow stem cells, then no phenotypic reversion is observed Henrix, 2007; Postovit, 2008
[36,37]
Ovarian, prostate, and breast cancer cells Microenvironmental exposure of human embryonic stem cells Reversion of malignant phenotype block of cancer cells in phase G1 These results led researchers to hypothesize an inhibitory action on the cell cycle by factors extracted from embryonic stem cells Giuffrida, 2009
[38]
Melanoma cells Microenvironmental exposure of human embryonic stem cells Reversion of malignant phenotype The study identified some mRNAs involved in these cellular reprogramming processes. Costa, 2009
[39]
Breast cancer cells Exposure to salamander, frog, and mouse embryonic cell extracts Stable reversal of malignant phenotype (confirmed with subsequent implantation of reprogrammed cells in immunosuppressed mice) Re-expression of some cancer suppressor genes has been observed; mouse embryonic cells did not give results Allegrucci, 2011
[40]
Breast cancer cells Exposure to embryonic extracts of zebrafish taken at different times of embryogenesis Reduction of invasiveness, migration, and proliferation parameters; action on cytoskeleton and TCTP downregulation An activation method of reversion was identified, implying the down-regulation of TCTP by exposing the cells to a specific embryonic microenvironment composition that corresponds to a specific phase of embryogenesis Proietti and Bizzarri, 2019
[12]