Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 27;22(4):145–152. doi: 10.1136/ebmental-2019-300109

Table 1.

Model input parameters

Parameters Values References
Base case Minimum Maximum
Probabilities
ETB sensitivity 0.957 0.870 1.000 P1vital
ETB specificity 0.400 0.610 0.190 P1vital
Response to first-line standard dose AD, moderate depression 0.530 0.600 GP survey7 14
Response to first-line standard dose AD, severe depression 0.670 0.600 GP survey7 14
Response to first-line standard dose AD, mild depression 0.350 0.360 GP survey; 60% of mild/moderate response rate16
Response to first-line increased dose AD, moderate depression 0.460 0.500 GP survey7
Response to first-line increased dose AD, severe depression 0.610 0.500 GP survey7
Response to first-line increased dose AD, mild depression 0.320 0.300 GP survey; 60% of mild/moderate response rate16
Response to second-line standard dose AD, moderate depression 0.510 0.410 GP survey15
Response to second-line standard dose AD, severe depression 0.630 0.410 GP survey15
Response to second-line standard dose AD, mild depression 0.380 0.246 GP survey; 60% of mild/moderate response rate16
Response to second-line increased dose AD, moderate depression 0.460 0.342 Identical base value to first-line AD (expert opinion)
Response to second-line increased dose AD, severe depression 0.610 0.342 Identical base value to first-line AD (expert opinion)
Response to second-line increased dose AD, mild depression 0.320 0.205 GP survey; 60% of mild/moderate response rate16
Response to secondary care AD therapy 0.400 Expert opinion
Full remission after response 0.410 7
Relapse, full remission no therapy (weekly) 0.017 18
Relapse, partial remission no therapy (weekly) 0.023 19
Relapse, full remission AD therapy (weekly) 0.007 18
Relapse, partial remission AD therapy (weekly) 0.009 19
Discontinuation, full remission (weekly) 0.044 17
Discontinuation, partial remission (weekly) 0.044 Same as for full remission (expert opinion)
Costs (£, 2011/2012)
First-line AD, standard dose (per week) 0.51 British National Formulary (BNF)
First- line AD, increased dose (per week) 0.76 BNF
Second-line AD, standard dose (per week) 0.51 BNF
Second-line AD, increased dose (per week) 0.76 BNF
Secondary care AD (per week) 0.71 0.94 BNF
Initial GP visit 44.00 25
Follow-up GP visit 30.00 25
Practice nurse, initial ETB test 7.17 0.00 7.17 25
Practice nurse, follow-up ETB test 0.00 0.00 7.17 25
Initial secondary care visit 264.75 353.00 25
Follow-up secondary care visit 45.75 91.50 25
Relapse treated in primary care (per week) 8.01 8.26 25
Relapse treated in secondary care (per week) 12.15 23.81 25
Utilities
Full remission, antidepressant therapy 0.810 0.680 0.940 16
Full remission, no therapy 0.850 0.720 0.980 23
Partial remission, antidepressant therapy 0.720 0.520 0.920 23
Partial remission, no therapy 0.760 0.560 0.960 Same improvement as in the case of full remission23
Mild depression 0.600 0.540 0.650 24
Moderate depression 0.460 0.300 0.480 24
Severe depression 0.270 0.210 0.340 24
Relapse 0.600 0.540 0.650 Same QoL impact as initial episode (expert opinion)
No of work days lost (per week)
Moderate depression 0.5 1.5 GP survey
Mild depression 0.2 0.6 GP survey
Severe depression 1.7 4.8 GP survey
Full remission, antidepressant therapy 0 Expert opinion
Full remission, no therapy 0 Expert opinion
Partial remission, antidepressant therapy 0 Expert opinion
Partial remission, no therapy 0 Expert opinion
Value of a work day saved (£) 119 48.64 27 28
Willingness to pay threshold (£/QALY) 30 000 20 000 30 000 20 22

AD, antidepressant; ETB, P1vital Oxford Emotional Test Battery; GP, general practitioner; QALY, quality-adjusted life year; QoL, quality of life.