Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 25;26(6):106735. doi: 10.1016/j.isci.2023.106735

Table 3.

Loss L on combined set (test set or training set) of finally trained models for compared methods

Methods L (TeWoR)a L (TeWR)a L (TrWoR)a L (TrWR)a
Fine-tune 5.299 5.257 5.298 5.256
IID-Offline 3.519 3.571 3.521 3.572
EWC 6.986 7.071 6.984 7.074
SI 4.899 4.938 4.897 4.934

BufferSize|M|=1K

ER 11.267 10.982 11.283 10.991
ER-RM 5.186 5.195 5.187 5.192
NI-WLb 5.172 5.061 5.172 5.060
NI-WL-RDb 4.356 4.391 4.358 4.391
NI-WL-RMb 4.766 4.830 4.769 4.831
NI-WL-RM-KDb 4.631 4.782 4.632 4.776

BufferSize|M|=5K

ER 4.182 4.188 4.182 4.188
ER-RM 4.596 4.759 4.599 4.760
NI-WL 4.740 4.790 4.737 4.792
NI-WL-RD 4.172 4.386 4.170 4.388
NI-WL-RM 4.400 4.319 4.402 4.320
NI-WL-RM-KD 4.162 4.200 4.168 4.197

BufferSize|M|=10K

ER 3.754 3.799 3.755 3.800
ER-RM 4.616 4.707 4.614 4.704
NI-WL 4.607 4.513 4.609 4.514
NI-WL-RD 4.542 4.510 4.540 4.508
NI-WL-RM 4.182 4.182 4.180 4.180
NI-WL-RM-KD 4.028 4.045 4.029 4.047

Bold underline, italic underline, and underline font highlights the first place, second place, and third place with same BufferSize, respectively.

a

TeWoR is short for test set without rotation, TeWR is short for test set with rotation, while TrWoR is short for training set without rotation, and TrWR is short for training set with rotation.

b

NI-WL, NI-WL-RD, NI-WL-RM, and NI-WL-RM-KD are four variants of our proposed method.