Skip to main content
. 2022 Oct 12;13(3):873–896. doi: 10.1177/21925682221129220

Table 1.

Studies on the Accuracy or Reliability of Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Diagnosis of Posterior Ligamentous Complex injury.

Author Objectives Levels Data collection Number of Patients Number of reviewers MRI field strength Definition of PLC Injury Key Findings
Aly et al (2022) Frequency of change of fracture classification by MRI compared to CT alone T1-L5 Retrospective 244 4 1.5 T and 3 T MRI Black stripe discontinuity due to SSL or LF rupture MRI changes the fracture classification in 10 % of cases. Perfect agreement on MRI evaluation of PLC(k = .89).
Mehta et al (2021) To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of MRI in PLC injury compared to intraoperative findings T1-L3 Prospective 58 2 Not specified Black stripe discontinuity due to SSL or LF rupture MRI sensitivity for intact PLC components ranged from 100% SSL to 66.67% LF. MRI specificity ranged from 100% ISL to 52% thoracolumbar fascia.
Lee et al (2015) To evaluate spine MRI inter-reader and intra-reader reliabilities for the TLICS score Thoracolumbar Retrospective 100 1 1.5 T and 3 T MRI Not specified Inter-reader agreement of MRI was fair to moderate (k = .440 for the first and .389 for the second review) for PLC integrity. Intra-reader agreement was .423-.616. Experience did not influence difference in inter-reader agreement
Pizones et al(2013) To study MRI accuracy for detecting PLC injury T1-L5 Prospective 58 3 Not specified Black stripe discontinuity due to SSL or LF rupture MRI sensitivity for injury diagnosis of each isolated PLC component varied between 92.3% ISL and 100% LF 100% SSL. PLC integrity sensitivity and specificity as a whole were 91% and 100%.
Vaccaro et al (2009) To study MRI accuracy for detecting PLC injury compared to intraoperative findings T1-L3 Prospective 42 1 Not specified Any high signal intensity with or without black stripe discontinuity MRI sensitivity for the various components of the PLC ranged from 79% left FC to 90% ISL. The specificity ranged from 53% thoracolumbar fascia to 65% LF, the PPV ranged from 70.4% left FC to 78.4% ISL, and the NPV ranged from 50.0% thoracolumbar fascia to 88.2% right FC.
Dai et al (2009) To measure the reliability of MRI in detecting PLC injury. T11-L1 Retrospective 61 3 1.5-Tesla MRI Any high signal intensity with or without black stripe discontinuity The kappa coefficients for ISL or SSL injury ranged .601 to .736, representing substantial to almost perfect agreement.
Schweitzner et al (2007) To determine the interrater reliability of indicators of PLC integrity on MRI and CT T3-L3 Retrospective 13 13 16-slice CT
1.5-Tesla MRI
1) facet joint diastasis on CT; (2) high signal intensity in the region of PLC components on sagittal T2W FAT SAT MRI; and (3) discontinuity of black strip on sagittal T1W MRI Absolute interrater percent agreement on facet diastasis and posterior edema-like signal in the region of PLC components on sagittal T2-weighted MRI was similar (agreement 70.5%).Facet joint diastasis on CT was the most reliable indicator of PLC disruption (κ = .395).
Haba et al (2003) To assess the diagnostic accuracy of MRI in detection of PLC injury compared to intraoperative findings T2-L5 Retrospective 35 3 .5-1.5-tesla MRI Any high signal intensity with or without black stripe discontinuity The diagnostic accuracy of MR imaging in detecting injury of the SSL and ISL was 90.5 and 94.3%, respectively. T1W MRI alone was more specific injury than T2W MRI alone. The overall mean κ coefficient for MR imaging findings of PLC injury was .803,and was greater for ISL (κ = .915) compromise than SSL (κ = .69) compromise.
Lee et al (2000) To assess the reliability of MRI for PLC injury in thoracolumbar spinal fractures. Thoracolumbar Prospective 34 1 Not specified A wide interspinous gap compared with the adjacent interspinous spaces on palpation or plain radiography (more than a 20% increase SSL injury was suspected on MRI in 27 patients, ISL in 30 patients, and LF in 9 patients. There were 28 SSL injuries, 29 ISL injuries, and 7 LF injuries in operative findings. There was a significant relation between MRI interpretation and operative findings.
Emery et al (1989) To review the accuracy MRI findings of patients with PLC injury compared to CT alone Thoracolumbar Retrospective 37 NR 1.0 T or 1.5 Tesla MRI Any high signal intensity with or without black stripe discontinuity MRI detected ligament damage in 17/19 (89%) cases of PLC injury. However, the only misdiagnosed thoracolumbar PLC injury was the only MRI performed without T2 sequences and performed at an outside hospital

Abbreviations: MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; SSL, supraspinous ligament; PLC, posterior ligamentous complex; CT, computed tomography; LF, ligamentum flavum; FC, facet joint capsules; ISL, interspinous ligament.