Skip to main content
. 2023 May 23;22(6):2114–2123. doi: 10.1021/acs.jproteome.2c00812

Table 1. Comparison of the Nine Evaluated Packages and Tools in Different Metrics and Propertiesa.

  Open source It has been benchmarked QC reports Input intensity data type Normalization method(s) Imputation method(s)
MSstats Pep Equalize median, Quantile, Global standards Accelerated failure time model, cutoffCensore, censoredInt, MaxQuantileforCensored
msqrob2 × Pep quantiles, quantiles.robust, vsn, center.median, center.mean, max, sum, div.mean, div.median, diff.median ×
ProStaR × Pep/Prot Global Quantile alignment and Centering, Column sums, vsn, LOESS Det quantile, slsa, KNN, fixed value
Proteus × Pep/Prot Equalize median, Quantile Mean-variance (by limma package)
prolfqua Pep/Prot robust scale Group mean imputation
ProVision × × Prot × Normal distribution like Perseus
LFQ-Analyst Prot × Normal distribution like Perseus, KNN, bpca, QRILC, MLE, MinDet, MinProb, min, zero
Eatomics × Prot VSN Normal distribution like Perseus, KNN, MinDet, QRILC
Perseus × Prot Z-score, remove batch effect, Un-Z-score A down-shifted Gaussian distribution, constant, ImputeLCMD
a

The input intensity data type refers to the intensity data supported by the package: (Pep) peptide intensity; (Prot) protein intensity.