Table 1. Comparison of the Nine Evaluated Packages and Tools in Different Metrics and Propertiesa.
Open source | It has been benchmarked | QC reports | Input intensity data type | Normalization method(s) | Imputation method(s) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MSstats | √ | √ | √ | Pep | Equalize median, Quantile, Global standards | Accelerated failure time model, cutoffCensore, censoredInt, MaxQuantileforCensored |
msqrob2 | √ | √ | × | Pep | quantiles, quantiles.robust, vsn, center.median, center.mean, max, sum, div.mean, div.median, diff.median | × |
ProStaR | √ | √ | × | Pep/Prot | Global Quantile alignment and Centering, Column sums, vsn, LOESS | Det quantile, slsa, KNN, fixed value |
Proteus | √ | √ | × | Pep/Prot | Equalize median, Quantile | Mean-variance (by limma package) |
prolfqua | √ | √ | √ | Pep/Prot | robust scale | Group mean imputation |
ProVision | √ | × | × | Prot | × | Normal distribution like Perseus |
LFQ-Analyst | √ | √ | √ | Prot | × | Normal distribution like Perseus, KNN, bpca, QRILC, MLE, MinDet, MinProb, min, zero |
Eatomics | √ | × | √ | Prot | VSN | Normal distribution like Perseus, KNN, MinDet, QRILC |
Perseus | × | √ | √ | Prot | Z-score, remove batch effect, Un-Z-score | A down-shifted Gaussian distribution, constant, ImputeLCMD |
The input intensity data type refers to the intensity data supported by the package: (Pep) peptide intensity; (Prot) protein intensity.