Table 13.

Evaluation of Cameriere’s method [23] for age estimation in subadults. When two values are given, they correspond to the metrics obtained on males/females

Evaluation work	Population	n	Age	E (DA-CA)			AE (|DA-CA|)			SE	R2
				μ	σ	med.	μ	σ	med.
Kumaresan et al. [82]	Malaysian	426	5–15	− 0.41	1.08	–	0.89	–	–	–	–
Sharma and Wadhwan [88]	Indian	335	5–16	− 0.60	1.32	–	1.11	0.93	–	–	–
da Luz et al. [94]	Brazilian	930	8–15	− 1.08/− 1.03	1.13/1.14	–	1.27/1.26	0.91/0.88	1.06/1.13	–	–
	Croatian	924	8–15	− 1.20/− 1.19	1.25/1.36	–	1.38/1.39	1.05/1.16	1.16/1.11	–	–
Marinkovic et al. [136]	Serbian	423	5–15	− 0.38/− 0.38	0.93/0.92	–	–	–	–	–	–
Çarıkçıoğlu and Değirmenci [142]	Turkish	1024	6–16	− 0.51	0.90	–	0.77	0.68	–	–	–
Rivera et al. [66]	Colombian	526	6–14	− 0.08	0.69	+ 0.15/− 0.28	0.57/0.57	0.38/0.41	–	–	–
Cameriere et al. [152]	Italian	2630	4–17	–	–	–	0.72/0.73	0.60/0.61	–	–	–
Santana et al. [153]	American - Indian	57	6–17	− 1.36	1.47	− 1.02	1.55	–	1.05	–	–
	American - European	173	6–17	− 1.24	1.72	− 1.02	1.60	–	1.21	–	–
	American - Hispanic	130	6–17	− 1.24	1.52	− 0.96	1.48	–	1.15	–	–
Halilah et al. [154]	German	1000	5–16	− 0.64/− 0.38	0.91/0.88	− 0.36/− 0.34	0.92/0.76	–	0.79/0.64	–	0.85/0.83
Angelakopoulos et al. [155]	South African - Black	970	6–14	–	–	–	0.70	–	–	–	0.82
	South African - White	974	6–14	–	–	–	0.58	–	–	–	0.874
AlShahrani et al. [156]	Saudi	788	6–16	− 0.26	1.47	–	–	–	–	–	0.49
Różyło–Kalinowska et al. [157]	Polish	121	5–13	+ 0.17/+ 0.18	0.86/0.96	–	0.73/0.77	0.48/0.60	–	–	–
Shen et al. [158]	Chinese	748	5–13	− 0.39	0.04	–	0.81	0.02	–	–	–