Skip to main content
. 2023 Jun 8;18(6):e0286842. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0286842

Table 3. Robustness test results.

Variables Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Model 5
GVCP APL RCA GVCPat MEXPY
ROD 0.0051*** 0.0165*** 0.0057* 0.0071***
(2.5940) (4.2511) (1.8577) (3.6220)
RODIFR 0.0054***
(2.9798)
EPR 0.0705** 0.0671** -0.1046 -0.1211** 0.0295
(2.1715) (2.0717) (-1.3996) (-1.9801) (0.6627)
PGDP 0.0429 0.0451 0.0002 0.0602 -0.1168***
(1.4867) (1.5689) (0.0046) (1.2441) (-6.8708)
TAF -0.0103* -0.0102* -0.0415*** -0.0369*** -0.0433***
(-1.7010) (-1.7122) (-3.5627) (-3.7410) (-7.6782)
REX -0.0347*** -0.0326*** -0.1212*** 0.0788*** 0.0878***
(-2.7433) (-2.5907) (-3.7866) (2.8341) (7.3676)
IEF 0.0344 0.0310 0.2512** 0.2004* -0.2446***
(0.6775) (0.6065) (2.0520) (1.8976) (-5.3362)
EMP -0.0177* -0.0175* 0.1773*** -0.0009 0.0135
(-1.7769) (-1.7578) (9.6192) (-0.0506) (1.3767)
EXP -0.0060 -0.0056 0.0147 -0.0251** 0.0049
(-1.3427) (-1.2615) (1.3429) (-2.1866) (0.8831)
IMP -0.0208** -0.0213** -0.0230 -0.0237* 0.0319***
(-2.2787) (-2.3568) (-1.4916) (-1.7210) (4.3687)
Constant 1.0127*** 1.0117*** 0.5364 0.2599 484.1383***
(4.3644) (4.3884) (1.1261) (0.6174) (1,879.1267)
National YES YES YES YES YES
Industry YES YES YES YES YES
Year YES YES YES YES YES
N 10260 10260 10260 10260 10260
R2 0.9768 0.9742 0.9587 0.9395 0.9735