Skip to main content
. 2023 May 24;23(11):5022. doi: 10.3390/s23115022

Table 1.

Summary of methods to identify gait events from running using data from a single wearable on the shank or sacrum/lower back. M—male; F—female; NR—not reported; FF—forefoot; RF—rearfoot; SS—self-selected; α—acceleration; ω—angular velocity; SCS—segment coordinate system; WCS—wearable coordinate system; GCS—global coordinate system (coordinate conventions defined below). IC—initial contact; TC—terminal contact; RL—right/left.

Sensor
Location
Method Sample Foot-Strike Speed Surface Placement Signals Sampling
Frequency
Events Ground Truth Sync
Shank Mizrahi [36] n = 14 (14 M)
Healthy
NR 3.5 ± 0.2 m/s Treadmill Tibial tuberosity aWCS,Y 1667 Hz IC None N/A
Mercer [27] n = 10 (10 M)
Healthy
NR 3.1–3.8 m/s Treadmill Anteromedial distal tibia aWCS,Y 1000 Hz IC, TC None N/A
Purcell [28] n = 6
Healthy
NR SS jog, run, and sprint Overground Anteromedial distal tibia aWCS,X,Y,&Z 250 Hz IC, TC Forceplate
1000 Hz
TTL pulse
Greene/McGrath [29,45] n = 5 (4 M; 1 F)
Healthy
RF 0.6–3.3 m/s Treadmill Anterior aspect of mid shank ωWCS,Z 102.4 Hz IC, TC MoCap
200 Hz
TTL pulse
Aminian/
O’Donovan
[35,46]
n = 1 (1 M)
Healthy
NR SS jog Overground Shank ωSCS,Z 102.4 Hz IC, TC MoCap
200 Hz
TTL pulse
Sinclair [37] n = 16 (11 M; 5 F) RF 4.0 ± 0.2 m/s Overground Anteromedial distal tibia aWCS,Y 1000 Hz IC, TC Forceplate
1000 Hz
Synchronous
recording
Whelan [30] n = 7 (3 M; 4 F)
National and
international sprinters
NR ≤50% max effort Overground Anteromedial
mid-tibia
aWCS,X 148.2 Hz IC Forceplate
1000 Hz
TTL pulse
Norris [31] n = 6 (1 M; 5 F)
Recreational
NR SS half-marathon training Overground Anteromedial distal tibia aWCS,Z 204.8 Hz IC None N/A
Schmidt [38] n = 12 (10 M; 2 F)
Track and field athletes
NR SS sprint Overground Lateral distal tibia aWCS,Y
ωWCS,Z
1000 Hz IC, TC Photocell NR
Aubol [39] n = 19 (9 M; 10 F)
≥16.1 km/wk
Injury free
RF 3.0 ± 0.2 m/s Overground Anteromedial distal tibia aWCS,X,Y,&Z 1000 Hz IC Forceplate
1000 Hz
Synchronous
recording
Fadillioglu [40] n = 13 (13 M)
Injury free
NR SS walking and running Overground Leg ωWCS,Z 1500 Hz IC, TC Forceplate
1000 Hz
TTL pulse
Bach [43] n = 21 (13 M; 8 F)
Healthy
NR 2.2 ± 0.1 m/s Treadmill Anteromedial proximal tibia aWCS,X,Y,&Z 142.9 Hz IC, TC Forceplate
1000 Hz
NR
Sacrum/Lower back Auvinet [32] n = 7 (7 M)
“top-level”
RF 5.2 ± 0.1 m/s Overground Lumbar spine aWCS,X,Y,&Z 100 Hz IC, TC, RL MoCap
200 Hz
Photoflash
Lee [33] n = 10 (6 M; 4 F)
National standard runners
NR 2.8–5.3 m/s Treadmill Sacrum (S1) aWCS,X&Z 100 Hz IC, TC, RL MoCap
100 Hz
Vertical movement
Wixted [34] n = 2
Nationally ranked
NR 5.9–6.2 m/s Overground Lumbar spine (L3–L4) aWCS,X&Y 500 Hz IC, TC Insoles
500 Hz
Synchronous collection
Bergamini [41] n = 11 (7 M; 4 F)
Amateur and national track and field team
NR 5.7–10.8 m/s Overground Lumbar spine (L1) ωWCS,X,Y,&Z 200 Hz IC, TC Forceplate/Mocap
200 Hz/300 Hz
Hammer tap/
none
Benson [44] n = 54 (29 M; 25 F)
Recreational
FF and RF 2.7–3.6 m/s Treadmill and
Overground
Lower back aWCS,X,Y,&Z 201 Hz IC, TC, RL Forceplate
1000 Hz
Vertical jump
Reenalda [42] n = 20 (15 M; 5 F)
≥15 km/week; no injuries
FF and RF 3.1–4.2 m/s Treadmill Sacrum aGCS,Y 240 Hz interpolated to 1000 Hz IC Forceplate
1000 Hz
x-correlated MoCap