|
Treatment modality |
Mechanisms of action (reference) |
Effects (reference) |
Possible adverse effects/ Disadvantages (reference) |
Other considerations (reference) |
|
Silicone gel sheets |
Collagen remodeling by local increasing of oxygen and temperature, hydration, chemical effects, increasing number of mast cells, and polarizing scar tissue (7) |
Increased elasticity, decreased pruritus and erythema, decreased scar thickness and height (42), especially effective in fresh scars (47), |
Folliculitis, lack of efficacy on mature scars (47) |
Effectiveness in preventing burn scars is conflicting (46) |
Compression garments |
Inhibition of TGF-β1 secretion and thereby attenuating fibroblast activity (42), Reduction of collagen production through reducing blood flow at the site of injury and thereby reducing oxygen and nutrients transfer (47) |
Decreased scar thickness and hardness, decreased erythema (42) |
Low patient compliance and adherence (<40%) because of discomfort, appearance, and movement difficulties (42) |
Efficacy is highly depending on the anatomic position of the injured are (47) |
|
|
|
Skin rash, erosion, pruritus, swelling, skeletal deformities (47) |
|
Intralesional corticosteroid injections |
Inhibition of inflammation and immunosuppression, vasoconstriction, inhibition of fibroblast and keratinocyte proliferation (47) |
Increased pliability, decreased height and volume of scars, decreased pain and pruritus (46, 47) |
High rate of adverse effects (up to 60%) including hypopigmentation, skin atrophy, telangiectasias, rebound effects, ineffectiveness and injection pain. |
Improved efficacy if combined with other therapies, decreased adverse effects in combination with 5-FU (47) |
|
|
|
Variable response rate (50-100%), possibility of recurrence (9-50%) (47) |
|
Laser and light therapy |
Based on the type of laser: collagen remodeling, induction of necrosis in the target capillaries and therefore reduction of vascularity (46) |
Increased pliability, decreased erythema, scar height and volume, pain, pruritus, color, and abnormal texture (46) |
|
|
Fat grafting |
Efficacy is mainly attributed to adipose-derived stem cells that may change fibroblast ECM production (46) |
Enhancement of wound closure, increased pliability, decreased fibrosis, decreased scar height and skin hardness (46) |
|
|
Interferons (α, β, γ) |
Enhancement of collagen breakdown, inhibition of TGF-β and fibrosis by IFN-γ, inhibition of proliferation by IFN-α2b (47) |
Improved appearance of scars, decreased recurrence of keloid scars (47) |
Painful injections, Flu-like adverse effects (47) |
An expensive therapy, but a promising method to treat extreme scarring (47) |
|