Table 2.1.
Types of traditional systematic reviews
| Review type | Topic assessed | Elements of research question (mnemonic) |
|---|---|---|
| Intervention59,61 | Benefits and harms of interventions used in healthcare. | Population, Intervention, Comparator, Outcome (PICO) |
| Diagnostic test accuracy62 | How well a diagnostic test performs in diagnosing and detecting a particular disease. | Population, Index test(s), and Target condition (PIT) |
| Qualitative | ||
| Cochrane63 | Questions are designed to improve understanding of intervention complexity, contextual variations, implementation, and stakeholder preferences and experiences. |
Setting, Perspective, Intervention or Phenomenon of Interest, Comparison, Evaluation (SPICE) Sample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation, Research type (SPIDER) Perspective, Setting, Phenomena of interest/Problem, Environment, Comparison (optional), Time/timing, Findings (PerSPecTIF) |
| JBI64 | Questions inform meaningfulness and appropriateness of care and the impact of illness through documentation of stakeholder experiences, preferences, and priorities. | Population, the Phenomena of Interest, and the Context (PICo) |
| Prognostic65 | Probable course or future outcome(s) of people with a health problem. | Population, Intervention (model), Comparator, Outcomes, Timing, Setting (PICOTS) |
| Etiology and risk66 | The relationship (association) between certain factors (e.g., genetic, environmental) and the development of a disease or condition or other health outcome. | Population or groups at risk, Exposure(s), associated Outcome(s) (disease, symptom, or health condition of interest), the context/location or the time period and the length of time when relevant (PEO) |
| Measurement properties 67,68 | What is the most suitable instrument to measure a construct of interest in a specific study population? | Population, Instrument, Construct, Outcomes (PICO) |
| Prevalence and incidence69 | The frequency, distribution and determinants of specific factors, health states or conditions in a defined population: eg, how common is a particular disease or condition in a specific group of individuals? | Factor, disease, symptom or health condition of interest, the epidemiological indicator used to measure its frequency (prevalence, incidence), the population or groups at risk as well as the context/location and time period where relevant (CoCoPop) |