Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 15;275:120116. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2023.120116

Table 9.

Test-retest reliabilities of adult ERP peak amplitude and mean amplitude studies.

Paper Age(s) at First Test Sample Size Time to Retest ERP Measure(s) Reliability (ICC)
Taylor et al. (2016) 19–28 years N = 32 1–2 weeks CNV O-wave Component Mean 0.58
CNV E-wave Component Mean 0.19
Total CNV Mean 0.05
N1 Baseline-to-Peak 0.41
N1 Peak-to-Peak 0.26
P2 Baseline-to-Peak 0.74
P2 Peak-to-Peak 0.71
N2 Baseline-to-Peak 0.65
N2 Peak-to-Peak 0.47
P3 Baseline-to-Peak 0.75
P3 Peak-to-Peak 0.57
Lin et al. (2020) 18–30 years N = 53 1–3 weeks ERN Peak-to-Peak 0.69
Pe Peak-to-Peak 0.74
Weinberg and Hajcak (2011) Mean age of 21.12 years N = 26 1.5–2.5 years ERN Peak 0.62
CRN Peak 0.55
ΔERN Peak 0.60
Area Under the ERN 0.62
Area Under the CRN 0.72
Area Difference ΔERN 0.66
Area Under the Pe 0.68
Area Around the ERN Peak 0.66
Area Around the CRN Peak 0.66
Area Around the Δpeak 0.56
Levinson et al. (2017) Undergraduates N = 59 1 week RewP Mean 0.62
FN Mean 0.81
ΔRewP Mean 0.43
Fallgatter et al. (2001) 22–60 years N = 23 30 min P300 Go Peak 0.85
P300 NoGo Peak 0.92
Brunner et al. (2013) Median age 27.5 years N = 26 6–18 months P3 NoGo Wave Peak 0.81
IC P3 NoGo Early Peak 0.85
IC P3 NoGo Late Peak 0.80
Hämmerer et al. (2012) Younger adults (mean age = 24.27 years) N = 47 2 weeks P2 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.83
N2 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.79
P3 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.56
P2-N2 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.76
P2 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.59
N2 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.63
P3 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.64
P2-N2 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.67
Older adults (mean age = 71.24 years) N = 47 2 weeks P2 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.75
N2 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.76
P3 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.77
P2-N2 Peak CPT Go Trials 0.67
P2 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.83
N2 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.73
P3 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.70
P2-N2 Peak Reinforcement Learning Task (Avg Gain/Loss) 0.78
Cassidy et al. (2012) 19–35 years old N = 25 1 month P1 Peak 0.76
N1 (P08) Peak 0.87
N1 (P07) Peak 0.91
P3a Peak 0.77
P3a Difference Peak 0.64
P3b Peak 0.77
P3b Difference Peak 0.52
ERN Peak 0.74
ERN Difference Peak 0.87
Pe Peak 0.71
Pe Difference Peak 0.85
P400 Peak 0.85
N170 Peak 0.84
ERN Peak-to-Peak 0.76
ERN Difference Peak-to-Peak 0.56
P3a Mean 0.78
P3a Difference Mean 0.82
P3b Mean 0.80
P3b Difference Mean 0.73
Pe Mean 0.62
Pe Difference Mean 0.74
P400 Mean 0.85
Area Under the P3a 0.78
Area Difference P3a 0.82
Area Under the P3b 0.83
Area Difference P3b 0.59
Area Under the Pe 0.54
Area Difference Pe 0.78
Area Under the P400 0.80
Huffmeijer et al. (2014) 18–22 years N = 10 4 weeks VPP Mean 0.95
N170 Mean (Avg Left/Right) 0.91
MFN Mean 0.09
P3 Mean (Avg Left/Right) 0.63
LPP Mean 0.85
Segalowitz et al. (2010) Mean age of 28.2 years N = 11 20 min ERN (Fz) Peak-to-Peak 0.66
ERN (FCz) Peak-to-Peak 0.79
ERN (Cz) Peak-to-Peak 0.73
Sinha et al. (1992) Mean age of 36.48 years N = 44 14 months Visual N1 Peak (Avg Oz, Cz, Pz) 0.69
Visual N2 Peak (Avg Oz, Cz, Pz) 0.66
Visual P3 Peak (Avg Cz, Pz) 0.69
Auditory N1 Peak (Cz) 0.66
Auditory N2 Peak (Cz) 0.47
Auditory P3 Peak (Avg Cz, Pz) 0.56
Kinoshita et al. (1996) 29–52 years N = 10 1 week P300 Baseline-to-Peak 0.49
N100 Baseline-to-Peak 0.58
N200 Baseline-to-Peak 0.51
N100-P300 Peak-to-Peak 0.48
N200-P300 Peak-to-Peak 0.54
Rentzsch et al. (2008) 19–51 years N = 41 4 weeks P50 Base-to-Peak 0.86
N100 Base-to-Peak 0.71
P200 Base-to-Peak 0.82
P50 Peak-to-Peak 0.89
N100 Peak-to-Peak 0.70
P200 Peak-to-Peak 0.78
Malcolm et al. (2019) Mean age of 24.2 years N = 12 Mean of 2.3 years Frontocentral N2 Mean 0.42
Central N2 Mean 0.61
Centroparietal N2 Mean 0.28
Frontocentral P3 Mean 0.61
Central P3 Mean 0.61
Centroparietal P3 Mean 0.40
Thesen and Murphy (2002) Younger adults and elderly N = 20 4 weeks N1 Baseline-to-Peak 0.51
P2 Baseline-to-Peak 0.27
P3 Baseline-to-Peak 0.50
N1-P2 Peak-to-Peak 0.55
N1-P3 Peak-to-Peak 0.52
D.M. Olvet and Hajack (2009) Undergraduates N = 45 2 weeks CRN Peak 0.58
ERN Peak 0.70
ERN-CRN Difference Peak 0.51
Area Under the CRN 0.78
Area Under the ERN 0.70
Area Difference ERN-CRN 0.47
Area Under the Pe 0.75
Larson et al. (2010) 19–29 years N = 20 2 weeks ERN Mean 0.66
CRN Mean 0.75
Pe Mean (Error Trials) 0.48
Pe Mean (Correct Trials) 0.68
Sandre et al. (2020) Mean age of 18.2 years N = 33 5 months ERN Peak (Cz) 0.67
ERN Peak (FCavg) 0.57
CRN Peak (Cz) 0.67
CRN Peak (FCavg) 0.66
ΔERN Peak (Cz) 0.47
ΔERN Peak (FCavg) 0.39
ERN Peak-to-Peak (Cz) 0.56
ERN Peak-to-Peak (FCavg) 0.39
CRN Peak-to-Peak (Cz) 0.54
CRN Peak-to-Peak (FCavg) 0.21
ΔERN Peak-to-Peak (Cz) 0.46
ΔERN Peak-to-Peak (FCavg) 0.15
ERN Mean (Cz) 0.62
ERN Mean (FCavg) 0.59
CRN Mean (Cz) 0.71
CRN Mean (FCavg) 0.62
ΔERN Mean (Cz) 0.46
ΔERN Mean (FCavg) 0.26
Suchan et al. (2018) 20–28 years N = 14 28 days ERN Peak (Cz) 0.89
CRN Peak (Cz) 0.74
ERN-CRN Difference Peak (Cz) 0.63
ERN Peak (FCz) 0.95
CRN Peak (FCz) 0.75
ERN-CRN Difference Peak (FCz) 0.79
Area Under the ERN (Cz) 0.83
Area Under the CRN (Cz) 0.80
Area Difference ERN-CRN (Cz) 0.74
Area Under the ERN (FCz) 0.81
Area Under the CRN (FCz) 0.68
Area Difference ERN-CRN (FCz) 0.59
Hall et al. (2006) 19–55 years N = 19 Mean of 17.8 days MMN Peak 0.67
P300 Peak 0.86
P50 Peak (Conditioning Paradigm) 0.56
P50 Peak (Testing Paradigm) 0.57
MMN Mean 0.66
Wang et al. (2021) 18–25 years N = 16 3–4 days Duration-Related MMN Peak 0.70
Frequency-Related MMN Peak 0.73
Lew et al. (2007) 18–58 years
(Healthy Control Group)
N = 21 Median of 6.5 days N1 Peak 0.66
MMN Peak 0.60
P3 Peak 0.84
N4 Peak 0.63
20–53 years
(TBI Group)
N = 7 Median of 6.5 days N1 Peak 0.70
MMN Peak 0.21
P3 Peak -0.02
N4 Peak 0.31
Light and Braff (2005) Adults (Schizophrenia Group) N = 10 Mean of 578 days MMN Mean 0.77
Chen et al. (2018) 20–26 years N = 20 7 hours MMN Mean (Happy Silent Movie Task) 0.41
MMN Mean (Happy 2-Back Working Memory Task) 0.11
MMN Mean (Angry Silent Movie Task) 0.29
MMN Mean (Angry 2-Back Working Memory Task) 0.48
2 weeks MMN Mean (Happy Silent Movie Task) 0.40
MMN Mean (Happy 2-Back Working Memory Task) 0.54
MMN Mean (Angry Silent Movie Task) 0.49
MMN Mean (Angry 2-Back Working Memory Task) 0.24
Jiao et al. (2022) Adults (Schizophrenia Group) N = 34 2 days Duration-Related MMN Peak > 0.60
Frequency-Related MMN Peak < 0.40