Table 2.
Reported limitationa | Examples | No. of reporting limitations (n = 71) | Potential bias (under- or overestimation) |
---|---|---|---|
Results not generalizable outside study setting/population | Restricted geographic coverage; population restrictions (e.g. hospitalized or medically attended patients only); assessment of single season | 29 | Under or over |
Sampling period | Sampling not tailored to RSV season (e.g. use of influenza season) | 18 | Under |
Sampling gaps within study period | |||
Sample size | Small sample size leading to unstable estimates | 11 | Under or over |
Testing method | Quality or sensitivity issues relating to PCR testing | 10 | Under |
Lack of serology | |||
Not testing all eligible population | Significant proportion not sampled | 10 | Under (incidence) |
Suboptimal case definitions | Definitions of ARI, ILI or choice of required symptoms for inclusion may miss RSV cases, as RSV may not feature fever or cough | 9 | Under |
Duration between enrolment and viral testing | Viral shedding reduces over time and virus may disappear from sample site | 5 | Under |
Sampling method | Single sampling site (e.g. nasopharyngeal only; serology only) | 5 | Under |
Suboptimal duration or method of sample storage |
ARI, acute respiratory illness; ILI, influenza-like illness; RSV, respiratory syncytial virus
aOnly issues specifically reported by study authors as limitations are included