Skip to main content
. 2023 Jun 19;23:212. doi: 10.1186/s12876-023-02853-w

Table 1.

List of studies included in the quantitative analysis and Network Meta-Analysis. NS: not statistically significant according to preplanned statistical analysis

Author/year/
study name
Phase study/
Country
N° randomized patients Study arms Hematological toxicity G3-4
(exp arm)
N/NF/PLT/Hb
Nonhematological toxicity G3-4
(exp arm)
N/V/mucositis/diarrhoea/neurotoxicty
mPFS in months A/B mOS in months A/B Primary endpoint Bias

Oettle/ 2014/

CONKO-003

III/Germany 168 Folinic acid + fluorouracil (FF) (arm A) vs. FF + oxaliplatin (OFF) arm B NR/NR/1/3 3*/NR/0/3

2.0/2.9

 h = 0.68 (SS)

3.3/5.9

 h = 0.66 (SS)

OS LOW

Wang-Gillam/ 2019/

NAPOLI-1

III/Global 417 5-FU/LV (arm A) vs. NALIRI + 5-FU/LV (arm B) vs. NALIRI (arm C) 15.4/NR/5.1/NR NR/6/NR/9.4/NR

1.5/3.1

 h = 0.57 (SS)

4.2/6.2

 h = 0.75 (SS)

OS LOW
Ohkawa/ 2015 IIR/Asia 271 S-1 (arm A) vs. SOX (S-1 + oxaliplatin) (arm B) 8/NR/10/8 6.6/2.9/1.5/5.1/2.9

2.8/3.0

 h = 0.84 (NS)

6.9/7.4

 h = 1.03 (NS)

PFS SOME CONCERN
Ioka/ 2017 IIR/Asia 137 S-1 (arm A) vs. IRIS (S-1 + irinotecan) (arm B) 4.6/NR/4.7/15.6 6.3/3/1.6/3.1/NR

1.9/3.5

 h = 0.77 (NS)

5.8/6.8

 h = 0.75 (NS)

OS SOME CONCERN

Hurwitz/ 2015/

RECAP

IIR/Western 127 Capecitabine (arm A) vs. capecitabine + Ruxolitinib (arm B) 0/NR/1.7/15.3 5/5/6.8/5/1.7

NA

HR = 0.75 (NS)

4.3/4.5

 h = 0.79 (NS)

OS SOME CONCERN

Hecht/ 2021/

SEQUOIA

III/Global 567 FOLFOX (arm A) vs. FOLFOX + Pegilodecakin (arm B) 29.5*/NR/25/16 4/4/NR/4/2

2.1/2.1

 h = 0.98 (NS)

5.8/6.3

 h = 1.04 (NS)

OS LOW

Gill/ 2016/

PANCREOX

III/Canada 108 mFOLFOX6 (arm A) vs. 5FU/LV (arm B) 32.7*/4.1/8.2/2 NR/4/NR/2/4

3.1/2.9

 h = 0.90 (NS)

6.1/9.9

 h = 1.68

OS LOW

Chiorean/ 2021/

SWOG S1513

IIR/USA 123 FOLFIRI (arm A) vs. FOLFIRI + Veliparib (arm B) 34*/NR/NR/7 12/9/NR/11/NR

2.9/2.1

 h = 1.39

6.5/5.4

 h = 1.23 (NS)

OS SOME CONCERN

Ioka/ 2018/

GRAPE

III/Asia 603 TAS-118 (S-1 + LV) (arm A) vs. S-1 (arm B) 1.7/NR/1.7/6 1.7/2/6.7/7.3/NR

3.9/2.8

 h = 0.80

7.6/7.9

 h = 0.98 (NS)

OS LOW