Skip to main content
. 2023 Jun 19;13:9934. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-37129-6

Table 6.

Experimental Results of the HCOA and BPSO-CM for f16-f29. The OE are at the end of the table.

Function The HCOA BPSO-MC
16 MV Std MV Std
5.341E+03 1.670E+03 5.223E+03 1.189E+03
17 MV Std MV Std
3.904E+03 7.662E+02 4.450E+03 8.408E+02
18 MV Std MV Std
1.410E+06 7.889E+05 1.385E+06 8.217E+05
19 MV Std MV Std
6.651E+03 8.455E+03 7.050E+03 6.119E+03
20 MV Std MV Std
3.334E+03 7.455E+02 3.226E+03 5.726E+02
21 MV Std MV Std
9.704E+02 1.128E+02 1.008E+03 1.382E+02
22 MV Std MV Std
2.382E+04 8.733E+03 1.952E+04 7.287E+03
23 MV Std MV Std
1.218E+03 1.235E+02 1.237E+03 1.232E+02
24 MV Std MV Std
1.786E+03 1.527E+02 1.768E+03 1.913E+02
25 MV Std MV Std
7.598E+02 6.408E+01 7.723E+02 5.521E+01
26 MV Std MV Std
1.335E+04 1.706E+03 1.336E+04 1.886E+03
27 MV Std MV Std
5.000E+02 5.205E−04 5.000E+02 3.802E−04
28 MV Std MV Std
5.000E+02 5.282E−04 5.000E+02 3.109E−04
29 MV Std MV Std
3.768E+03 6.099E+02 3.799E+03 7.298E+02
OE 68.97% 31.03%