Skip to main content
. 2023 Jun 3;9(6):e16974. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e16974

Table 1.

Physicochemical characteristics, advantages, and limitations of some alternative proteins.

Alternative proteins Nutritional characteristics Advantages Limitations References
Plant-based protein Soy
  • Protein: 40%

  • Crude fat: 20%.

  • Carbohydrate: 33–35%.

  • PDCAAS: 90–99%.

  • Effect against chronic diseases and cancer.

  • Good emulsifying and water and oil absorption capacity.

  • High lysine and isoflavone concentration.

  • Off-flavors due to lipoxygenases content.

  • Low in methionine and cysteine.

  • High allergenicity.

[11,19,47]
Pea
  • Protein: 23–30%.

  • Crude fat: 1.5–2%.

  • Carbohydrate: 35–40%.

  • Fiber (%): 60–65%.

  • PDCAAS: 73–89%.

  • Gluten-free.

  • Low allergenicity.

  • High levels of lysine and a good source of antioxidants.

  • Low levels of methionine and cysteine.

[138]
Coconut
  • Protein: 3.6–5.5%.

  • Crude fat: 20–44%.

  • Carbohydrate: 6–15%.

  • Fiber (%): 2–9%.

  • Total EAA: 71–77%.

  • PDCAAS: 86–94%.

  • High content of monounsaturated fatty acids.

  • Increase the HDL (high-density lipoprotein) levels.

  • High saturated fats.

  • Low in methionine, isoleucine, threonine, and tryptophan.

[44,139]
Almond
  • Protein: 21%.

  • Crude fat: 49%.

  • Carbohydrate: 21%.

  • Fiber: 12.5%.

  • PDCAAS: 32–34%.

  • Source of alpha-tocopherol and manganese.

  • Low in calories.

  • High allergenicity limits its use as a beverage.

  • Low protein solubility at acidic pH.

[11,44]
Oat
  • Protein: 9–20%

  • Crude fat: 5–9%.

  • Fiber: 2–8%.

  • PDCAAS: 41–60%.

  • Gluten-free.

  • Therapeutic benefits.

  • High fiber content.

  • Hypocholesterolemia properties.

  • Source of antioxidants and polyphenols.

  • Use limited in liquid or semi-solid products because of their high starch content.

  • Limited lysine content.

  • Low foaming capacity due to high lipid content.

  • Low protein solubility at acidic pH.

[11,52,126]
Rice
  • Protein: 7–76%.

  • Crude fat: 0.2–20%.

  • Carbohydrate: 18–76%.

  • Fiber (%): 0.06–13%.

  • Total EAA: 41%.

  • PDCAAS: 90%.

  • High levels of leucine, phenylalanine, and methionine.

  • Use limited in liquid or semi-solid products because of their high starch content.

  • Low protein content.

  • Limited lysine content.

  • Emulsion stability is very low due to the high starch content.

  • Low protein solubility at acidic pH.

[11,140,141]
Single-Cell Protein Algae
  • Protein: 51–93%.

  • Crude fat: 4–22%.

  • Carbohydrate: 1–17%.

  • Nucleic acid: 3–8%.

  • Antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activity.

  • Sources of vitamins and minerals.

  • High levels of leucine, lysine, and valine).

  • Low allergenicity.

  • Unpleasant flavor (fishy flavor) and odor.

  • Non-homogeneous appearance.

  • High nucleic acid content.

  • Intense color.

  • Low efficiency and high production costs.

  • High cellulose content.

[5,21,70,84,142]
Bacteria
  • Protein: 50–83.5%.

  • Crude fat: 1–10%.

  • Carbohydrate: 6.83%.

  • Nucleic acid: 8–14%.

  • High growth rate.

  • Highest methionine content.

  • High nucleic acid.

  • Small cell sizes can potentially hinder purification steps.

  • Endotoxins content.

  • High risk of contamination.

[21,84,86]
Fungal (filamentous fungi and yeast)
  • Protein: 30–60%.

  • Crude fat: 2–3%.

  • Carbohydrate: 38–54%.

  • Fiber (%): 3–4%.

  • PDCAAS (%): 94–95%.

  • Nucleic acid: 3–12%.

  • High protein content.

  • More resistant to shear stress.

  • Rapid growth.

  • Insulinotropic protein.

  • High B vitamin content.

  • High lysine content.

  • Mycotoxins content

  • Cytotoxicity

  • Low methionine content.

[21,92,143]
Recombinant protein Unknown
  • Therapeutic properties.

  • Effective bioprocess optimization.

  • Posttranslational modifications.

  • Co-secretion of proteases.

  • Potential functionality changes.

  • Low yield.

  • Mutations.

[13,25,144]

*%Protein: g/100g of dry basis.