Table 1. Type of research studies and approvals/exemptions.
Type of studies | Details about the need for approvals | |
---|---|---|
Studies involving interaction or intervention | ||
1. Clinical Trials- pilot, all phases and designs | A pilot study with an intention to contribute to general knowledge (fits the criteria for research) | |
All phases of clinical trials require separate approvals. | ||
2. All interventional studies | Even those using standard of care or non-pharmacologic interventions need approval. | |
3. Diagnostic tests and devices | Analysis of data and biologic specimens need approvals. | |
4. Medical records review | Those identifying private identifying information need approvals. | |
5. Case reports | 1–3 cases don’t require IRB approvals, preferably patient consent should be taken for it nevertheless. | |
Case series need approvals as they are hypothesis testing. | ||
6. Quality improvement and cost benefit analysis | Whenever it fits the definition of research, i.e., intent to generalize knowledge present. | |
7. Product evaluations | Whenever it fits the definition of research, i.e., intent to generalize knowledge present. | |
8. Public health surveillance | Those mandated by law, e.g., reporting of communicable diseases are exempt from IRB review. | |
Studies not involving direct interaction or intervention | ||
1. Use of preexisting medical records or stored specimens | IRB review required if identifying information is recorded. | |
2. Databases, registries, biobanks of biomedical specimens | IRB review required for confidentiality purposes. | |
Surveys/Interviews | Collection of identifying or sensitive information requires IRB approval. |
IRB = Institutional Review Board.