Table 1.
Clinical cases assessing the role of medicinal plants in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcer
Scientific name
|
Family
|
Sanskrit name
|
Country
|
Parts used
|
Sample size
|
Other ingredients
|
Mode of administration
|
Metabolites or nutraceuticals along with result
|
Duration
|
Inference of the study
|
Ref.
|
Actindia deliciosa | Actinidiaceae | Kiwi | Iran | Fruit | 37 | NR | Injection (3 mm thick layer) every 12 h | Actinidin and ascorbic acid/angiogenesis (increased), epithelialization, vascularization and granulation. Ulcer size (decreased) | 11.24 ± 3.66 d (experimental), 17.76 ± 4.88 d (control) | Complete wound healing and effective | Mohajeri et al[35] |
Actindia deliciosa | Actinidiaceae | Kiwi | Iran | Fruit | 18 | Eucerin cream | Topical (wound was covered with the mixture) every 24 h | Actinidin, wound size (decreased) (0.94 ± 0.58 cm2), experimental vs control (% change in wound size: -1.25 ± 0.21 vs 0.21 ± 0.05) | 28 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Kardoust et al[36] |
Ageratina pichinchensis | Asteraceae | - | Mexico | Aerial part | 36 | Cold cream | Topical one a week | 7-O-(β-D-glucopyranosyl)-galactin/wound size (decreased) | 65.47 ± 47.08 d experimental); 77.46 ± 50.80 d (control) | Complete wound healing and effective | Romero-Cerecero et al[37] |
Calendula officinalis | Asteraceae | Zergul | Brazil | Flowers | 32 | NR | Topical (5 mL) once a day | Calendula oil/wound healing (increased), pain (decreased) | 30 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Carvalho et al[73] |
Calendula officinalis | Asteraceae | Zergul | Brazil | Flowers | 84 | NR | Spray twice daily | Wound healing (increased), 78% had complete healing after 30 wk | 15.5 ± 6.7 wk | Reduction in wound size and effective | Buzzi et al[74] |
Garcinia kola | Clusiaceae | Balya | Nigeria | Seed | 120 | NR | Oral (capsule) 250-500 mg | Wound healing (increased), Reduction in wound size by 63.30% in experimental group | 63-84 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Bolajoko et al[24] |
Kalanchoe pinnata | Crassulaceae | Pranabijah | West Indies | Leaves | 478 | NR | Plaster (boiled leaf) and poultice once to thrice daily | Wound healing (increased) | 9 d | Effective | Cawich et al[99] |
Linum usitatissimum | Linaceae | Atasi | Iran | Seed oil | 60 | NR | Supplement (1000 mg/d omega-3 fatty acid from flaxseed oil) | Omega-3- fatty acid/ulcer length (decreased), width and depth, experimental vs control % change in (ulcer length: -2.0 ± 2.3 vs -1.0 ± 1.1 cm; width: -1.8 ± 1.7 vs -1.0 ± 1.0 cm; and depth: -0.8 ± 0.6 vs -0.5 ± 0.5 cm) | 84 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Soleimani et al[25] |
Melilotus officinalis | Fabaceae | Vanamethika | Iran | NR | 10 | NR | Intravenous infusion | Melilotus/wound (decreased) size (reduced by 50%), experimental vs control (wound size: 6.69 ± 60 vs 12.32 ± 11 cm2) | 56 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Bagheri et al[113] |
Melilotus officinalis | Fabaceae | Vanamethika | Iran | NR | 40 | NR | Orally twice a day | Melilotus/wound healing (increased), experimental vs control (completely healed: 90.0% vs 70.0%) | 84 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Bahrami et al[114] |
Momordica charantia | Cucurbitaceae | Karavella | Indonesia | Leaf | 30 | NR | Oral (6 g) per day | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control: [TNF-α serum levels (pg/mL): -29.50 ± 8.6 vs -202.47 ± 610.2; PEDIS degree (decreased): 1.9 ± 0.6 vs 2.2 ± 0.8] | 28 d | Not effective | Rosyid et al[122] |
Olea europaea | Oleaceae | Jaitun | Iran | Fruit | 60 | NR | Topically (oil) once a day | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control (completely healed: 76.60% vs 0.00%) | 28 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Abdoli et al[130] |
Olea europaea | Oleaceae | Jaitun | Iran | Fruit | 34 | NR | Topical (oil) once a day | Wound healing (increased). Ulcer area (decreased) and depth, experimental vs control (completely healed: 73.33% vs 13.30%; change in ulcer (area: -54.7% ± 28.8% vs +2.7% ± 47.2%), depth (area: -60.1% ± 13.8% vs -29.6% ± 12.6%) | 28 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Nasiri et al[131] |
Plantago major | Plantaginaceae | Asvagola | Iran | Leaves | 94 | Gel | Topically (oil) once a day | Plantamajoside/wound healing (increased), experimental vs control (completely healed: 64.00% vs 20.50%) | 14 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Ghanadian et al[125] |
Plantago major and Aloe vera | Plantaginaceae, Asphodelaceae | Asvagola and Ghrit kumara | Iran | NR | 40 | NR | Intervention twice a day | Ulcer surface decreased, ulcer depth decreased | 28 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Najafian et al[55] |
Plectranthus amboinicus and Centella asiatica | Lamiaceae and Apiaceae | Yavani, Mandukaparni | Taiwan | NR | 24 | Cream (composed of cetostearyl alcohol, ireine, liquid petrolatum, methyl paraben propyl paraben, Span 60, Tween 60, white petrolatum, water, and pigments) | Topically (2 mm thickness) twice a day | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control [improved Wagner grade: 90.9% vs 70.0% (% change in wound size: -27.18 vs -22.64)] | 14 d | Reduction in wound size and effective but not significant compared to controlled group | Kuo et al[84] |
Quercus infectoria | Fagaceae | Mayakku | Thailand | Nutgalls | 51 | Ethanol | Topical once a day | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control (80.7% vs 20.0%) | 96 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Chokpaisarn et al[152] |
Sesamum radiatum and Azadirachta indica | Pedaliaceae and Meliaceae | Tila, Nimba | India | Seed and leaves | 15 | Ghee and honey | Topically (3 mm thick) once a day | Wound size and exudates (decreased), no granulation, reduction in wound size by 88.0% in the experimental group | 45 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Tripathy et al[160] |
Teucrium polium | Lamiaceae | - | Iran | Aerial part | 70 | Eucerin | Topically twice daily | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control; ulcer area (decreased): 0.717 ± 0.19 cm2 vs 1.63 ± 0.72 cm2 | 28 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Fallah Huseini et al[169] |
Tinospora cordifolia | Menispermaceae | Guduchi | India | NR | 50 | NR | Intervention | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control (change in ulcer area: 0.15 cm2/d vs 0.07 cm2/d; ulcer perimeter: 0.09 cm2/d vs 0.07 cm2/d; ulcer depth: 2.20 cm2/d vs 1.40 cm2/d; wound score: 14.40 cm2/d vs 10.60 cm2/d; no. of debridements: 1.90 cm2/d vs 2.50 cm2/d) | 28 d | Reduction in wound size and effective | Purandare and Supe[176] |
Vasconcellea cundinamarcensis | Caricaceae | - | Brazil | Latex | 50 | NR | Intervention thrice a week | Wound healing (increased), experimental vs control. Completely healed: 68.7% vs 31.3%) | 112 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Tonaco et al[182] |
Vernonia amygdalina | Asteraceae | - | Nigeria | Leaves | 120 | NR | Oral (capsule) 250-500 mg/kg body weight | Wound healing (increased), reduction in wound size by 60.0% in experimental group | 63-84 d | Complete wound healing and effective | Bolajoko[26] |
NR: Not reported; TNF-α: Tumour necrosis factor alpha.