Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Jun 29.
Published in final edited form as: Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2022 Jan 1;54(1):169–180. doi: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000002773

Table 2:

Recommendations for future research.

Essential Additional

Participants
 Sex/Age/Race Include male and female subjects as well as subjects with different race and ethnicity. Investigate adolescents and older subjects, because they are underrepresented in the current literature.
 Inclusion criteria Use pre-specified inclusion criteria based on age, sex, and level of fitness. Depending on the research question consider including further criteria, such as training history, habitual exercise time or chronotype.
 Blinding Ensure that subjects are unaware of the performance they achieved at a certain time of the day until the end of the study. Blind the investigator analyzing the data.
 Sample size A priori sample size needs to be performed at least for the primary outcome of the study. If subgroup analyses are planned (e.g. for different chronotypes) the sample size needs to be adequate for these analyses too.

Measurements
 Time points Measure at least five time points during the day. Previous studies mainly focused on the time windows from 07:00 to 20:00. Consider investigating broader time windows.
 Gold standard Use gold standard methods for each outcome. Ensure that the test-retest reliability is sufficient to enable showing the difference anticipated in the sample size calculation.
 Outcomes If two or more outcomes are measured pre-specify the primary one. For all studies investigating strength performance we recommend to include hand grip strength, countermovement jump and isometric mid-thigh-pull-up to the protocol.
 Familiarization Perform at least one familiarization trial. Time trials for example might require more than one familiarization trial.
 Calibration Ensure that the devices are calibrated in sufficient intervals according to the recommendation of the manufacturer.
 External factors Ensure equal preparation (i.e. warm-up, preparation before test) and equal external factors (i.e. room temperature, humidity).
 Randomization Randomize the sequence of time points measured.
 Verification Implement methods to ensure that subjects actually reached their maximum (e.g. secondary VO2max criteria). Measure each time of the day twice to ensure that the pattern of diurnal variation seen is repetitive and to assess the coefficient of variation at each time of the day.
 Regeneration Ensure sufficient regeneration time between tests. The required duration will depend on the task and can be short for tasks like hand grip strength test but may be long for long duration time trials. Include physiological markers (e.g. blood) to ensure the regeneration.

Monitoring during study period
 Sleep Give instructions to maintain a constant sleeping routine. Use diaries, questionnaires or ideally objective methods to monitor sleep.
 Physical activity Give instructions how long to refrain from exercise before each test. Use diaries, questionnaires or ideally objective methods to monitor activity.
 Nutrition Give instructions such as allowed diets, required fasting durations before the tests, or time windows subjects are allowed to eat. Use diaries, questionnaires or ideally less subjective methods such as recording nutrition and meal timing by taking pictures with a reference sized measure.

Reporting
 Study Report everything that is recommended by CONSORT.
 Results Report effect sizes or mean differences including 95% confidence intervals
 Real data Report data as it is measured (e.g. L/min, N, s, cm – ideally SI-units) and not only as percentage values. Report absolute and relative data (e.g. L/min and mL/kg/min or N and N/kg) and if possible report different units for the same outcome (e.g. jump height in cm, flight time in s, and peak power N/kg for the countermovement jump).
 Times of day Report all times of the day tested and not only the peak and nadir.
 Deviations Report if the actual test time deviated from intended test time.
Report for which outcomes and time points data is missing.
 Outcomes Report all outcomes measured or provide an explanation if some outcomes are not reported.