Table 1.
Source | Quality (AMSTAR) | Population | Population definition | Search period | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Score | Quality | Pain type | Sample size, n | Studies, n | Pain duration | ||
Owen et al. (5) | 11/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 5578 | 89 RCTs | ≥12 weeks | Inception to 05/2019 |
Bernard et al. (25) | 9/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 200 | 6 RCTs | >12 weeks | Inception to 0/10/2018 |
Byström et al. (13) | 6/11 | Moderate | Chronic LBP | 1768 | 16 RCTs | >12 weeks | Inception to 10/2011 |
Gomes-Neto et al. (24) | 7/11 | Moderate | Chronic LBP | 895 | 11 RCTs | > 3 months + no leg pain | Inception to 11/2014 |
Luomajoki et al. (18) | 11/11 | High | LBP | 781 | 11 RCTs | Chronic LBP: > 3 months; subacute LBP: within 3–12 weeks | Inception to 04/2017 |
Macedo et al. (14) | 11/11 | High | Acute LBP | 197 | 3 RCTs | <6 weeks | Inception to 04/2015 |
Niederer et al. (23) | 6/11 | Moderate | Chronic LBP | 2391 | 18 RCTs | NA | Not applicable |
Niederer & Mueller (19) | 8/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 1081 | 10 trials | >6 weeks | Inception to 1/10/2018 |
Saragiotto et al. (10) | 11/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 2431 | 29 RCTs | >12 weeks | Inception to 04/2015 |
Smith et al. (21) | 7/11 | Moderate | LBP | NA | 29 RCTs | Pain or stiffness between lower rib and buttock crease (studies with specific pathology were excluded) | 10/2006 to 10/2013 |
Wang et al. (12) | 8/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 414 | 5 RCTs | >3 months | 1970 to 10/2011 |
Zhang et al. (22) | 8/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 1333 | 18 RCTs | >12 weeks | Inception to 08/2020 |
Hayden et al. (17) | 10/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 20,969 | 217 RCTs | >12 weeks | Not applicable |
Searle et al. (20) | 8/11 | High | Chronic LBP | 4462 | 45 RCTs | Pain and discomfort localized below the costal margin and above the inferior gluteal folds lasting more than 3 months | Inception to 30/10/2014 |
Zhang et al. (72) | 7/11 | Moderate | Chronic LBP | 950 | 18 RCTs | Physician-diagnosed for more than 3 months | Inception to 01/05/2021 |
AMSTAR, Assessment of multiple sytematic reviews; RCT, randomized controlled trial; LBP, low back pain.