Table 3.
The test performance on the FreeSolv-PHYSPROP dataset. Each model is trained on 50 random splits and the mean and standard deviation are reported. sPhysNet-MT-ens5 is a deep ensemble of five sPhysNet-MT models. The errors in hydration free energies are reported in kcal/mol and the errors in logP are reported in log unit.
Ref. | Model | Target | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hydration (FreeSolv) | logP (PHYSPROP) | ||||
MAE | RMSE | MAE | RMSE | ||
sPhysNet-MT | 0.392±0.064 | 0.663±0.135 | 0.262±0.006 | 0.421±0.017 | |
sPhysNet-MT-ens5 | 0.359±0.063 | 0.620±0.140 | 0.242±0.004 | 0.393±0.012 | |
Previous hydration free energy prediction models | |||||
36 | SVM | --- | 0.852±0.171 | --- | --- |
XGBoost | --- | 1.025±0.185 | --- | --- | |
RF | --- | 1.143±0.230 | --- | --- | |
DNN | --- | 1.013±0.197 | --- | --- | |
GCN | --- | 1.149±0.262 | --- | --- | |
GAT | --- | 1.304±0.272 | --- | --- | |
MPNN | --- | 1.327±0.279 | --- | --- | |
Attentive FP | --- | 1.091±0.191 | --- | --- | |
40 | 3DGCN | 0.575±0.053 | 0.824±0.140 | --- | --- |
42 | AGBT | 0.594±0.090 | 0.994±0.217 | --- | --- |
39 | D-MPNN | --- | 0.998±0.207 | --- | --- |
37, 68 | weave | --- | 1.220±0.280 | --- | --- |
43 | A3D-PNAConv | 0.417±0.066 | 0.719±0.168 | --- | --- |
69 | FML | 0.570 | --- | --- | --- |
Previous logP prediction models | |||||
70 | QSPR | --- | --- | --- | 0.78 |
60 | GraphCNN | --- | --- | --- | 0.56 |
71 | --- | --- | --- | 0.47±0.02 | |
--- | --- | --- | 0.50±0.02 | ||
72 | OPERA | --- | --- | --- | 0.78 |