Table 3.
Outcome | Quality assessment | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Required domains | Additional domains | Grade | |||||||
Study limitations | Consistency | Directness of evidence | Precision | Reporting bias | Dose-response association | Plausible confounding that would decrease the observed effect | Strength of association (magnitude of effect) | ||
Asthma | Higha | Inconsistentb | Indirect | Precisec | Undetectedd | Undetected | Presente | Weakf | Low |
Allergic rhinitis | Higha | Inconsistentb | Indirect | Precisec | Unestimableg | Undetected | Presente | Weakf | Very low |
aAll included studies are observational in design
bConsiderable heterogeneity (I2 > 50%)
cVery large sample size (over 4000)
dAccording to Egger’s regression test (p = 0.578)
eAll included studies had an observational design, and there was a difference in adjusted variables depending on each study
fOR < 2.0
gDue to insufficient included studies to evaluate publication bias