Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 6;13:10948. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-37309-4

Table 3.

Summary of findings and certainty assessment.

Outcome No. of studies Effect (SDM-Z) Design Risk of Bias Inconsistency Indirectness Imprecision Publication bias Certainty of the evidence
Resting-state brain activity (seed to whole-brain rsFC) 8 1.70 (anterior cingulate); −1.85 (left supramar-ginal gyrus) Cross-sectional studies; RCTs No serious risk of bias No serious inconsistencies Serious (healthy controls only) No serious imprecision No serious publication bias

 ⊕  ⊕  ⊝  ⊝ 

Low (due to small number of studies and indirectness)

Resting-state brain activity (seed-based rsFC, other synchronization parameters) 9 Not pooled Cross-sectional studies; RCTs No serious risk of bias Some inconsistencies No serious indirectness No serious imprecision

 ⊕  ⊕  ⊝  ⊝ 

Low (due to small number of studies and inconsistencies)

Resting-state brain activity (fALFF) 5 Not pooled Cross-sectional studies; RCTs No serious risk of bias Some inconsistencies No serious indirectness No serious imprecision

 ⊕  ⊕  ⊝  ⊝ 

Low (due to small number of studies and inconsistencies)

Task-based brain activity 7 Not pooled Cross-sectional studies; RCTs Some risk of bias Some inconsistencies No serious indirectness No serious imprecision

 ⊕  ⊕  ⊝  ⊝ 

Low (due to small number of studies and inconsistencies)

Structural change (grey and white matter volume) 8 Not pooled Cross-sectional studies; RCTs No serious risk of bias Some inconsistencies No serious indirectness No serious imprecision

 ⊕  ⊕  ⊝  ⊝ 

Low (due to small number of studies and inconsistencies)

rsFC resting-state functional connectivity, fALFF fractional amplitude of low-frequency fluctuations.