Skip to main content
. 2016 Feb 29;2016(2):CD007880. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007880.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Ackerman 1968 Tetracycline was one of the studied antibiotics; nowadays it is not recommended for the age range in our protocol
Arroll 2008 Review
Betend 1972 Trial is not about undifferentiated acute respiratory infections
Bloomfield 2004 Trial conducted in hospitalised children with respiratory syncytial virus infection
Bovier‐Lapierre 1971 Trial is not about undifferentiated acute respiratory infections
Carr 1973 There is no placebo or non‐treatment control group in this trial
Castello 1981 Not a RCT
De Mattia 1986 Comparison between 2 antibiotics. Ages of participants are not clearly stated
De Sario 1986 Study is not about undifferentiated respiratory infections
Easton 2010 Not a RCT
Gjelstad 2013 It is an article about medical education
Gordon 1974 Data about the effects of antibiotic compared to control in relieving symptoms, preventing complications or causing adverse events were not provided
Gronås 1971 Trial is a comparison of 2 antibiotics for respiratory infections probably caused by Haemophilus influenzae
Guerrier 1972 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Gupta 1977 Comparison among 3 antibiotics; there is no placebo or non‐treatment control group
Hardy 1956 Data for participants in our protocol age range were not available
He 2006 The entire text could not be accessed
Henness 1982 Study is a comparison among antibiotics; there is no placebo or non‐treatment control group
Higashi 2014 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Kundu 1976 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Lake 1971 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Lexomboon 1971 Data about the effects of antibiotics compared to control in relieving symptoms, preventing complications and causing adverse events in children included in our protocol age range were not available
Limson 1972 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Lines 1973 Trial is a comparison between 2 antibiotics
Little 1997 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Maeda 1999 Data for children included specifically in our protocol age range were not available
Masbernard 1979 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
McGuinness 1986 Study is a comparison among antibiotics; no placebo or non‐treatment control group
Newell 1970 Trial is not about undifferentiated acute respiratory tract infection
Oggero 1985 Trial is a comparison between 2 antibiotics
Pan 2000 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Price 1975 Trial is not about undifferentiated acute respiratory tract infections
Ratjen 2013 An article about cystic fibrosis
Reinert 1991 Data for children up to 5 years of age were not available
Rentsch 1980 Not a RCT. Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Roper 1970 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range
Taylor 1977 Trial was not about undifferentiated respiratory infections. Laboratory tests were used to exclude children with infections of bacterial aetiology
Todd 1981 There are insufficient data for the sample age range and for the outcomes that are the subject of this review
Varricchio 2006 In this trial 2 antibiotics are compared; there was no non‐treatment or placebo control group
Varricchio 2008 Trial about culture‐proven acute bacterial infection
Windorfer 1980 Comparison between 2 antibiotics; no placebo or non‐treatment control group
Zwart 2003 No subgroup analyses for our protocol age range
Zwart 2004 Ages of participants were outside our protocol age range

RCT: randomised controlled trial