Table 4.
Comparison of the effects of reminiscence therapy (N = 6)
| Authors (year) |
Theoretical framework | Research design |
Intervention | Dependent variables (Study results) |
|||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Contents | Methods | No. of times & Length (min) | ||||
| Cho (2001) |
Cognitive, psychosocial development, and life review theory |
Non-equivalent control group pre-posttest design |
Group & Simple |
Family and home, Disease and treatment, Religion |
Sharing memories with others |
4 times & 60 min |
Life satisfaction (*), Self-esteem |
|
Lee, Cho, Yoon, & Son (2008) |
N/A |
Non-equivalent control group pre-posttest design |
Group & Life review |
Hometown, Motivating of health, Family future plan |
Sharing memories with others and Horticultural therapy |
18 times & 120 min |
Life satisfaction (*), Self-esteem (*), Depression (*), Physiological indicators (*) |
|
Meléndez-Moral, Charco-Ruiz, Mayordomo-Rodríguez, & Sales-Galán (2013) |
N/A |
Non-equivalent control group pre-posttest design |
Group & Simple |
Hometown |
Sharing memories with others |
8 times & 60 min |
Life satisfaction (*), Self-esteem (*), Depression (*), Psychological well- being (*) |
| Sok (2015) | N/A |
Non-equivalent control group pre-posttest design |
Individual & Life review |
Hometown, Folk remedy, Philosophy and religion |
Viewing pictures |
4 times & 60 min |
Quality of life (*), Cognitive function (*) |
|
Yousefi, Sharifi, Tagharrobi, & Akbari (2015) |
N/A | RCT |
Group & Simple |
All about personal life |
Sharing memories with others |
6 times & 120 min |
Life satisfaction (*) |
|
Viguer, Satorres, Fortuna, & Meléndez (2017) |
N/A |
Non-equivalent control group pre-posttest design |
Group & Simple |
All about an individual’s daily life |
Sharing memories with others |
10 times & 120 min |
Depressed mood (*), Life satisfaction (*), Psychological well- being (*) |
* P-value < 0.05