Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb;104(2):79–87. doi: 10.1308/rcsann.2021.0046

Table 1 .

Summary of diagnosis and criteria for fundoplication in the included studies

Study Diagnosis of LPR Criteria for fundoplicationa
Carroll et al (2016)33 Symptoms of LPR and RSI >13 Diagnosis of LPR
Symptoms refractory to at least 3 months high-dose BD PPI
Had evidence of reflux with impedance testing
No motility disorder on manometry
Catania et al (2007)29 Symptoms consistent with LPR and RSI >19
FNE-proven laryngeal irritation
3 or more episodes of pharyngeal acid reflux or positive deMeester score on distal probe
Diagnosis of LPR
Primary aim of surgery was resolution of LPR symptoms
Iqbal et al (2008)22 Diagnosis made by ENT surgeon – criteria not specified Diagnosis of LPR
Ogut et al (2007)30 Not specified GORD, RSI >14
Sahin et al (2015)27 Laryngeal symptoms, RSI >13 and RFS >7 Responded to daily PPI therapy
Had at least one of heartburn and/or regurgitation
Suzuki et al (2017)34 Laryngeal symptoms Diagnosis of LPR
Weitzendorfer et al (2017)31 Not specified Ongoing LPR symptoms despite 6 months of PPI
Westcott et al (2004)32 Not specified Incomplete clinical response to medication
Medication intolerance, reflux-associated cancer or recurrent leucoplakia, reflux-associated subglottic stenosis, or patient desire for operative therapy in lieu of medical management
Zhang et al (2017)22 Laryngeal symptoms and positive pharyngeal pH testing Diagnosis of LPR

LPR = laryngopharyngeal reflux; BD = twice daily; PPI = proton pump inhibitor; FNE = functional nasoendoscopy; ENT = ear nose and throat (otolaryngology); GORD = gastro-oesophageal reflux disease

a All patients underwent fundoplication only if there was objective evidence of reflux identified by 24-h ambulatory pH or multichannel intraluminal impedance–pH monitoring or erosive esophagitis