Skip to main content
. 2016 Feb 26;2016(2):CD000360. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000360.pub5
Study Reason for exclusion
Aboulghar 1995 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Aboulghar 1996 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Agarwal 2004 Unexplained subfertility couples
Buvat 1990 Number of couples receiving IUI and TI was not stated
Crosignani 1994 Authors could not provide pre‐cross‐over data
Cruz 1986 Different comparison: IUI vs. ICI
Elizur 2004 Not an RCT, but a retrospective study
Elzeiny 2014 Unexplained subfertility couples
Evans 1991 Biochemical pregnancies only, no response from the author
Fan 2012 Oocytes were randomised between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Fishel 2000 Oocytes were randomised between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Friedman 1989 Preliminary report, different comparison: IUI vs. ICI
Galle 1990 Not an RCT, but an observational study
Goverde 2001 Not an RCT, correspondence
Hewitt 1985 Not an RCT, an observational study
Ho 1989 Authors could not provide pre‐cross‐over data
Ho 1992 Authors could not provide pre‐cross‐over data
Karlström 2000 Compares IUI both with different forms of OH
Kastrop 1999 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Kihaile 2003 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Kirby 1991 Authors could not provide pre‐cross‐over data
Li 2004 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Martinez 1991 Authors could not provide pre‐cross‐over data
Melis 1987 Different comparison: ICI in natural cycle vs. ICI with OH
Moolenaar 2015 Not an RCT, but a retrospective study
Nulsen 1993 Not an RCT: quasi randomised, biochemical pregnancies only
Pisarska 1999 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Plachot 2002 Not an RCT: oocytes were quasi randomised between IVF and ICSI
Prentice 1995 Not an RCT: quasi randomised, based on hospital case record number
Soliman 1993 Incomplete data on treatment of control group
te Velde 1989 Authors could not provide pre‐cross‐over data
Tournaye 2002 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
van der Westerlaken 2006 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Verheyen 1999 Oocytes were randomly divided between IVF and ICSI, no outcome data available per couple
Xie 2015 Not an RCT
Zayed 1997 Not an RCT: quasi randomised, patient preference

ICI: intra‐cervical insemination; ICSI: intracytoplasmic sperm injection; IUI: intra‐uterine insemination; IVF: in vitro fertilisation; OH: ovarian hyperstimulation; RCT: randomised controlled trial; TI: timed intercourse.