Table 1. Characteristics and methodological quality of included studies.
Studies | Nation | LOE | Study quality | Number of samples | BMI (kg/m2) Classification (Number of each group) | Age (years) (M± SD) | Sex (male: female) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Takeuchi H,. 2019 [14] | Japan | 2b | 7/9 | 63 | BMI<25: (36) BMI≥25: (27) | 55.6±16 | 49:14 |
Trinchieri A, et al. 2016 [19] | Italy | 3b | 7/9 | 1698 | BMI<18.5: (91) 18.5≤BMI<24.9: (924) 25≤BMI<29.9: (542) 30≤BMI: (141) | 45.9±14.6 | 984:714 |
Lee SC, et al. 2007 [20] | South Korea | 3b | 7/9 | 704 | BMI<25: (475) BMI≥25: (229) | 42.8±13.2 | 470:234 |
Ekeruo WO, et al. 2004 [21] | The USA | 3b | 7/9 | 1021 | BMI<25: (881) BMI≥25: (140) | 53.2±14.9 | ND |
Daudon M, et al. 2006(1) [22] | France | 3b | 7/9 | 1930 | BMI<25: (1259) 25≤BMI<30: (480) 30≤BMI: (191) | ND | 1370:561 |
Daudon M, et al. 2006(2) [23] | France | 3b | 7/9 | 2464 | BMI<25: (1416) 25≤BMI<30: (703) 30≤BMI: (345) | 53.6±11.4 | 1760:704 |
Chou YH, et al. 2010 [24] | Taiwan, China | 3b | 7/9 | 907 | 18.5≤BMI<25: (251) 25≤BMI<27: (304) 27≤BMI: (352) | 53.9±14 | 661:246 |
del Valle EE, et al. 2010 [25] | Argentina | 3b | 7/9 | 817 | BMI<24.9: (337) 25≤BMI<29.9: (322) 30≤BMI: (158) | ND | 459:358 |
Mosli HA, et al. 2012 [26] | Saudi Arabia | 2b | 7/9 | 173 | BMI<18: (5) 18.5≤BMI<24.9: (30) 25≤BMI<30: (64) 30≤BMI: (24) | 46.03±12.7 | 131:42 |
Al-Hayek S, et al. 2013 [27] | The USA | 3b | 7/9 | 325 | BMI<25: (88) 25≤BMI<30: (103) 30≤BMI: (134) | 51.8±12.5 | 162:163 |
Najeeb Q, et al. 2013 [28] | India | 3b | 7/9 | 100 | BMI<25: (28) 25≤BMI<30: (38) 30≤BMI: (34) | 38.49±13.72 | 70:30 |
Çaltık Yılmaz A, et al. 2015 [29] | Turkey | 2b | 6/9 | 84 | BMI<18: (52) 18≤BMI<25: (20) 25≤BMI: (12) | ND | 42:42 |
Fram EB, et al. 2015 [30] | The USA | 3b | 7/9 | 382 | BMI<25: (79) 25≤BMI<30: (140) 30≤BMI: (163) | 46.4±15 | 224:382 |
Shavit L, et al. 2014 [31] | The UK | 3b | 6/9 | 2132 | BMI<25: (833) 25≤BMI<30: (863) 30≤BMI: (436) | 46±15 | 1503:629 |
Almannie RM, et al. 2019 [32] | Saudi Arabia | 3b | 7/9 | 433 | BMI<18: (24) 18≤BMI<25: (81) 25≤BMI: (328) | ND | 316:117 |
LOE: level of evidence; BMI: body mass index; ND: not demonstrated.