Skip to main content
. 2023 Jun 27;23(13):5970. doi: 10.3390/s23135970

Table 3.

Advantages and disadvantages of specific prognostic and health-management techniques.

Pros. Cons. Application
Bayesian Network easy to understand and transparent
encodes expert knowledge
used for both RUL and RCA purposes
handles uncertainty
complex preparation process
both expert and analytical
knowledge required
finds only known/defined cases
fault detection [158]
diagnosis [194,195]
scheduling [196]
RUL [197,198]
SVM good modeling of non-linear and linear relationships
used for both regression and classification
does not require a large learning set
lack of transparency
data scientist’s knowledge needed
with large datasets, long computation times
fault detection [137,138,185]
condition monitoring [199,200]
PCA handles multidimensional datasets
works well with other techniques
generalizes the data
loss of some information
features lose linking to specific components
fault detection [131,132,201,202]
Expert system transparent and easy to understand
good interaction with domain knowledge
no need for a physical process model
advanced models require a strong effort
works only with defined cases
fault detection, planning [203]
fault detection [204,205,206]
Fuzzy logic extends the capabilities of the expert system to time series analysis
deals with input noise and uncertainty
requires knowledge to apply fuzzy rules fault detection [122]
diagnostics [207]
Physical models provide precise results for a specific
well-known case/process
algorithms understandable for industry experts
require considerable modeling effort and extensive domain knowledge RUL [208]
condition monitoring [209]
ANNs provide the capability to model complex, non-linear relationships
no domain knowledge required
can be used in conjunction with other techniques
provide direct result output
“black box” results may be non-transparent
prone to overfitting
difficult in determining the uncertainty of results
require a large training set
RUL [178,179]
ARIMA computationally efficient
does not require large datasets
requires no expert knowledge
short term forecast only
sensitive to noise and process variations
RUL [210,211,212,213,214]
HMMs allow modeling of both time series
and stationary data
handle incomplete datasets
computationally complex
do not detect previously undefined events
fault detection [126,127]
RUL [215,216]