Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 12;13(7):e069590. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-069590

Table 3.

Modelling assumptions

Theoretical basis Perspective Time horizon Forms of uncertainty explicitly considered*
CAPACITI Multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) embedded in broader problem-structuring framework Flexible N/A Parameter; criteria weighting
PriorityVax MCDA embedded in broader problem-structuring framework Flexible N/A Parameter;
criteria weighting
HIPtool Synthesise evidence Health system N/A
Optima Impact model: dynamic compartmental models; costing: logistic cost function model; global optimisation to minimise outcome (eg, DALYs) or costs to achieve defined outcomes Health system Do not know Parameter
OneHealth (spectrum suite) Impact model: module specific (eg, LiST for child and maternal health interventions, or TIME a dynamic compartmental model for TB); costing: ingredients-based costing Flexible 100 years fixed time horizon Parameter
LiST Impact model: static equation-based model; costing: ingredient-based costing Flexible Maximum until 2050 Parameter
EQUIST Bottleneck analysis and statistical analysis of changes to effective coverage based on strategies’ bottleneck reduction; impact analysis: based on LiST; costing: based on LiST and OneHealth Health system Maximum until 2050

*The two forms of uncertainty in the table include: (1) Parameter—uncertainty in tool input values; (2) criteria weighting—uncertainty in the relative importance of criteria (MCDA specific). Users can explore different scenarios using the tools, including EQUIST, which can be used to assess uncertainty. As this feature is not automated but requires developing new analyses we do not include it in the table. Other forms of uncertainty such as model structural uncertainty are not explicitly considered by the tool and are thus not included.

CAPACITI, Country-led Assessment for Priortisation in Immunisation; EQUIST, EQUitable Strategies to Save Lives Tool; HIPtool, Health Interventions Priortisation tool; LiST, Lives Saved Tool; MCDA, multicriteria decision analysis; N/A, not available.