Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 27;3(4):274–298. doi: 10.1021/acsmaterialsau.3c00002

Table 1. Studies Focusing on the Environmental Assessment of ALD and Relevant CVD Processes.

process studied methodology assessment boundaries main findings of the study ref
ALD of Al2O3 energy analysis precursor utilization, methane emissions, and nanowaste generations energy flow analysis demonstrates that the ALD process energy consumption is mainly determined by the ALD cycle time rather than the process temperature (44)
ALD of Al2O3 exergy analysis energies associated with material, heat, and work flow utilization of energy is extremely low in ALD Al2O3 process (49)
ALD of Al2O3 LCA cradle-to-grave ALD produces the highest environmental impact in the category of fossil fuel use; the impacts associated with the auxiliary infrastructure, equipment, and tools for ALD operation are intensive mainly due to the slow ALD cycling process (45)
ALD of Al2O3 gas and aerosol emissions analysis process emissions at the exhaust CH4 and C2H6 generated, emissions of ultrafine particles (diameter <100 nm) reduce with longer purging time (46)
ALD of Al2O3 DFT calculations on process wastes and methane emissions chemical reaction of the process: 2Al(CH3)3 + 3H2O → Al2O3 + 6CH4 high material waste (up to 60% of precursors); waste generated and methane emissions increase with pulse time; the moderate temperature of the chamber (200 °C) leads to less waste (47)
ALD of Al2O3 gas and nanoparticles emissions analysis process emissions at the exhaust 93% of TMA is discarded as waste; nanoparticles generated are harmful to humans; emissions decrease with purge time (48)
ALD of Al2O3 computational analysis 10-wafer ALD processing system emissions Al203 nanowastes generated from the ALD production system are grave concerns (56)
ALD of Zn(O,S) to replace CdS as buffer layer in CIGS photovoltaic cells LCA front end of a CIGS module ALD has 19–26 times lower environmental impacts than chemical bath deposition (CBD) of CdS for all categories but metal depletion (2.65 higher) (57)
ALD of ZnO LCA gate-to-gate majority of the impact is related to electricity consumption, and material usage is of minor importance (58)
Plasma-enhanced CVD (PECVD) of amorphous silicon (a-Si:H)/nc-SiOx,/SiNx and ALD of Al2O3 for silicon heterojunction solar cells LCA complete solar PV installation new SHJ designs based on PECVD and ALD have a better environmental performance compared to the reference SHJ design; PECVD requires more energy for thin film deposition than ALD (59)
low-pressure CVD (LPCVD) of TiO2 material and energy consumptions analysis material consumption: Ti(OC3H7)4(g) + 2H2O(g) → TiO2(s) + 4C3H7OH(g) precursor and energy utilization efficiencies < 1% (60)
Energy consumption: Energy for heating the reactor, energy for pumping, energy absorbed by the input gases, and energy of the chemical reaction
plasma-assisted CVD (PA-CVD) of SiOx LCA 1 m2 surface protected by a layer with a thickness of 1 μm PA-CVD involves high gross energy requirement (GER) and global warming potential (GWP) values (61)
CVD of TiCN-TiN-Al2O3 LCA cradle-to-gate thin film deposition process accounts for less than 10% of the total manufacturing energy of inserts for cutting tools; CVD is more energy-demanding than PVD (62)