Table 4.
Comparison of Human-exoskeleton coordinated control strategy.
Paper | Control approach | Advantages | Challenges |
---|---|---|---|
Amiri et al. (2019) | IMRAC | The comparison between the results of the IMRAC and conventional MRAC, shows the IMRAC converged faster and consumed less computational time than MRAC. | Lack of testing under disturbing conditions or in different environments. |
Liang et al. (2018) | Based on LSTM. | Comparison with statistical regression methods based on LSTM, is stable, disturbed only by missing data and outliers, and has better inter-individual adaption. | Adaptability to a large number of subjects was not tested. |
Zhang et al. (2019) | Based on hierarchical Lyapunov. | Compared with PD control, the moment of human-computer interaction can be minimized by setting appropriate controls. | There will be a delay in lower layer mode switching. |
Chen et al. (2022) | Based on NFO. | It has faster calculation speed and recognition accuracy than GA and PSO algorithms. | The stability is easily affected by the parameters of the PD controller. |
Ma et al. (2020) | Based on DMPs. | Trajectory features are extracted from sample trajectories, and new trajectories are constructed. | It is impossible to construct a general model, and information such as the subject's height and weight needs to be considered. |
Guo et al. (2020) | Based on Lw-CNN. | Compared with SVM, the intent recognition speed is faster, and the real-time control is better. | The recognition accuracy is affected by the window size, and the accuracy decreases significantly when the sliding rate decreases. |
Hua et al. (2019) | GA_PSO algorithm. | Compared with the sensitivity amplification control (SAC), the human-robot interaction is reduced by 0.6%, which reduces the burden of human-robot collaborative motion. | Gait conversion and label categories are not subdivided, and the recognition conversion efficiency is not high. |
Du et al. (2018) | Variable impedance controller and SMILC. | Compared with PD iterative learning control algorithm (PDILC), the tracking error of SMILC is more minor, and the control system is more stable. | SMILC is prone to jitter when the state trajectory reaches the sliding mode surface. |