Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 17;62(3):403–414. doi: 10.1007/s00411-023-01027-2

Table 4.

Comparison of concentration ratios observed in this study to those published elsewhere

Element Present study Other studies IAEA generic values
Earthworms
 As 0.28 0.11–0.131; 0.39–1.712 0.35–4.64a
 Cd 40.0 25.5–26.41; 1.61–19.52; 10.6–18.83; 0.604 2.29–123a
 Cu 0.74 0.55–5.732; 1.01–1.353
 Fe 0.07 0.804
 Mn 0.34 0.006–0.12a
 Mo 0.41 0.42–2.212
 Ni 0.21 0.04–2.84a
 Pb 0.21 22.0–65.03 0.01–16.4a
 Se 6.77 23.5–2712; 1.09–1.495
 U 0.32 0.08–0.316; 0.09–0.527; 0.22–0.428; 0.09–0.259
 Zn 15.6 2.40–2.701; 2.90–19.32; 1.15–1.753; 0.774 11.2–41.2a
Ground beetles
 Ba 0.04 0.002–0.00610
 Ca 0.15 0.04–0.4810
 Cd 1.51 0.2611; 20.812 0.84–160b
 Co 0.03 0.003–0.01210 0.01–0.02b
 Cu 0.63 0.8711; 2.13–5.4710
 Fe 0.005 0.002–0.00710
 Li 0.02 0.0006–0.00210
 Mg 0.24 0.29–1.4110
 Mn 0.21 0.02–0.0510
 Na 29.1 0.12–0.2010
 Ni 0.05 0.0111; 15.012 0.04–2.84b
 Rb 0.15 0.05–0.3310
 Sr 0.11 0.03–0.1210 0.24–7.60b
 Ti 0.001 1.7011
 U 0.001 0.0110; 0.00411 0.04–0.08b
 Zn 2.81 1.17–3.6710 1.20–14.4b

1Nannoni et al. (2011), 2Chen et al. (2014), 3Wang et al. (2018), 4Latifi et al. (2020), 5Yue et al. (2021), 6Oliver et al. (2008), 7Giovanetti et al. (2010), 8Lourenço et al. (2011), 9Mrdakovic Popic et al. (2012), 10Naccarato et al. (2020), 11O'Quinn (2005), 12Bednarska et al. (2016)

aGeneric values for annelids (IAEA 2014)

bGeneric values for arthropods (IAEA 2014)