Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 19;13:11676. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-38343-y

Table 2.

Comparison of the oral pathologists' diagnoses with and without deep-learning-assisted diagnoses.

Evaluator Normal [95% CI] SCC [95% CI] Others [95% CI] Macro [95% CI] Micro [95% CI]
Oral pathologist #1
 With assistive diagnosis 0.97 [0.968–0.979] 0.99 [0.984–0.989] 0.94 [0.929–0.942] 0.97 [0.960–0.966] 0.97 [0.958–0.965]
 w/o assistive diagnosis 0.75 [0.732–0.759] 0.88 [0.871–0.882] 0.79 [0.784–0.804] 0.80 [0.795–0.810] 0.79 [0.776–0.791]
Oral pathologist #2
 With assistive diagnosis 0.98 [0.978–0.986] 0.94 [0.936–0.947] 0.88 [0.870–0.885] 0.93 [0.929–0.939] 0.93 [0.927–0.937]
 w/o assistive diagnosis 0.91 [0.902–0.922] 0.85 [0.847–0.863] 0.82 [0.811–0.828] 0.86 [0.854–0.867] 0.83 [0.819–0.833]
Oral pathologist #3
 With assistive diagnosis 0.73 [0.714–0.741] 0.91 [0.896–0.909] 0.83 [0.823–0.839] 0.82 [0.806–0.818] 0.88 [0.879–0.889]
 w/o assistive diagnosis 0.56 [0.549–0.572] 0.82 [0.816–0.832] 0.71 [0.712–0.732] 0.70 [0.691–0.704] 0.81 [0.798–0.812]
Oral pathologist #4
 With assistive diagnosis 1.00 [0.998–0.999] 0.98 [0.979–0.984] 0.96 [0.950–0.959] 0.98 [0.976–0.980] 0.98 [0.976–0.982]
 w/o assistive diagnosis 0.97 [0.968–0.977] 0.97 [0.965–0.972] 0.90 [0.893–0.905] 0.95 [0.942–0.950] 0.95 [0.946–0.955]
Oral pathologist #5
 With assistive diagnosis 0.96 [0.948–0.964] 0.95 [0.945–0.953] 0.92 [0.917–0.928] 0.94 [0.941–0.949] 0.96 [0.952–0.959]
 w/o assistive diagnosis 0.92 [0.902–0.922] 0.89 [0.884–0.900] 0.86 [0.845–0.860] 0.89 [0.884–0.897] 0.91 [0.900–0.913]
Oral pathologist #6
 With assistive diagnosis 1.00 [0.996–0.997] 0.98 [0.979–0.968] 0.97 [0.963–0.968] 0.98 [0.982–0.985] 0.98 [0.980–0.983]
 w/o assistive diagnosis 0.94 [0.928–0.943] 0.85 [0.837–0.852] 0.75 [0.749–0.768] 0.85 [0.843–0.854] 0.85 [0.836–0.849]

95% CI 95% confidence interval.