Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 21;18(7):e0289128. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0289128

Table 4. Selected fixed effect and random effect estimates for the final stepwise model.

All Countries High-Income Low-Income Lower-Middle Upper- Middle
Equation Y = f (EA ARMI FC FDI ER) Y = f (EA FDI ER ARMI FC) Y = f (FC EA ER ARMI FDI) Y = f (EA FDI FC ARME ER) Y = f (EA ARME ARMI ER FDI FC)
Variables AVA AVA AVA AVA AVA
FEM REM REM FEM FEM
FC -6.79e-06 -4.10e-06 -0.0944 0.000841 0.000165
(0.0000104) (5.91e-06) (0.0703) (0.0058) (0.00108)
EA 0.2616*** 0.2341*** 0.1560** 0.2692*** 0.2523***
(0.0476) (0.0609) (0.0629) (0.0768) (0.0469)
ARME 0.0829 0.4690**
(0.0842) (0.2002)
ARMI 0.0029 0.2707 0.2217 0.1742
(0.1416) (0.1894) (0.1646) (0.3510)
FDI 0.0012 0.000904*** 0.0419 -0.1536* 0.0078
(0.0019) (0.000314) (0.0713) (0.0824) (0.0533)
ER 0.000143*** 0.00250*** -0.0020** 0.000161*** 0.00031
(0.0000544) (0.0007053) (0.00085) (0.0000464) (0.00024)
Constant 3.7150 0.6931 19.4104 5.6348 1.0143
No of Countries 101 32 11 28 30
No of years 22 22 22 22 22
R2 Within 0.2865 0.3829 0.2817 0.3363 0.3976
R2 Between 0.7988 0.5787 0.1888 0.5619 0.5462
R2 Overall 0.7643 0.5500 0.2087 0.5229 0.4843

Note: The symbols *, **, and *** represents 10%, 5%, and 1% significance level, respectively. Parentheses represent the robust standard error. FE and RE represent the Fixed effect and Random effect, respectively.