Table 2.
Description and outcome of the included studies.
No. | Study Ref. | Author/Year | Disease | Aim | Sample used | Method of mtDNA-cn assessment | mtDNA gene | nDNA gene | Finding | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Giulivi et al.(37) | Giulivi/2010 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and deletions, and mitochondrial activity | White blood cells | qPCR | ND1, ND4 | PK, APP | Higher mtDNA-cn and mtDNA deletions in ASD patients compared to controls; low NADH, low activity of complex I, high plasma pyruvate levels and lower pyruvate dehydrogenase activity; higher oxidative stress in ASD patients compared to controls | Mitochondrial dysfunction, mtDNA overreplication, and mtDNA deletions are more likely to occur in ASD have than typically developing children |
2 | Gu et al. (38) | Gu/2013 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and mitochondrial activity | Frontal cortex tissue | qPCR | ND1, ND4, CYTB | PK | Higher mtDNA-cn in ASD patients than in controls; defects in complexes I, III and V, and reduced PDH activity in ASD patients compared to controls | Mitochondrial dysfunction in the brain is associated with ASD |
3 | Tang et al. (29) | Tang/2013 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and mitochondrial activity | Temporal cortex tissue | qPCR | 12S rRNA | RNAseP | No differences in either mtDNA-cn or levels of the mitochondrial gene transcription factor TFAM or cofactor PGC1α in ASD patients and controls; altered mitochondrial dynamics, protein levels of mitochondria respiratory chain protein complexes, decreased Complex I and IV activities; decreased mitochondrial antioxidant enzyme SOD2; and increased oxidative DNA damage and mitochondrial membrane mass in ASD patients | Mitochondrial dysfunction in early childhood ASD |
4 | Napoli et al. (39) | Napoli/2014 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and deletions, and mitochondrial activity | White blood cells | qPCR | ND1, ND4 | PK, APP | Higher oxidative stress in patients with autism; higher rates of mitochondrial ROS production; higher mtDNA-cn; and increased mtDNA deletions | Molecular network linking mitochondrial function, OXPHOS and the inflammation/immune response in ASD |
5 | Chen et al. (40) | Chen/2015 | ASD | mtDNA-cn | Peripheral blood | qPCR | mtDNA primers (L39, H475) | HBB | Higher mtDNA-cn in ASD patients compared to controls; no significant correlations between mtDNA-cn and clinical features including paternal age, maternal age, age of onset, illness of duration, CARS score and ABC score in childhood autism | Elevated mtDNA-cn is associated with ASD, indicating mitochondrial dysfunction in children with autism |
6 | Yoo et al. (26) | Yoo/2016 | ASD | mtDNA-cn | Peripheral blood | qPCR | ND1, ND4, CYTB | PK | Higher mtDNA-cn in ASD patients than in unaffected sibs; significant correlations between mtDNA-cn and clinical phenotypes for language and communication in ASD | Mitochondrial dysfunction and elevated mtDNA-cn in ASD are related to the phenotype for communication |
7 | Wong et al. (41) | Wong/2016 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and deletions, and p53 gene copy ratios | Peripheral blood mononuclear cell | qPCR | ND1, CYTB | PK | Higher mtDNA-cn in ASD patients than in controls; higher incidence of mtDNA deletions in ASD patients and their fathers | Genome instability and altered mtDNA-cn in ASD |
8 | Valiente-Palleja et al. (27) | Valiente-Palleja`/2018 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and mtDNA mutations | White blood cells | ND1, ND4 | NP | Lower mtDNA-cn in ASD and ID patients than in controls; a total of 28.6% of ASD and 30.5% of ID subjects carried at least one putative pathogenic mtDNA mutation | Mitochondrial dysfunction in ASD and ID | |
9 | Carrasco et al. (42) | Carrasco/2019 | ASD | mtDNA-cn, oxidative stress, complexes, polymorphisms and gene expression of mitochondrial SOD2 | Buccal cells | qPCR | tRNA-Leu | B2M | Higher mtDNA-cn in ASD compared to controls, enhanced ROS generation; significantly lower levels of respiratory complex I and decreased complex I and IV activities; presence of C47T polymorphism in SOD2 gene results in Ala16Val change could affect the transport of the SOD2 enzyme to the mitochondrial matrix and increases oxidative stress | Involvement of mitochondrial biology in the development of ASD |
10 | Kim et al. (43) | Kim/2019 | ADHD | mtDNA-cn, methylation ratio of the D-loop region and PPARGC1A | Peripheral blood | qPCR | CYTB | PK | Higher mtDNA-cn in ADHD patients than in controls; decreased methylation ratio of PPARGC1A in ADHD | Mitochondrial dysfunction plays a role in the pathophysiology of ADHD |
11 | Singh et al. (28) | Singh/2019 | ASD | mtDNA-cn and mitochondrial activity | Peripheral blood mononuclear cell | qPCR | ND4, CYTB | PK | Lower mtDNA-cn in ASD than in controls; higher maximal oxygen consumption rate, maximal respiratory capacity and reserve capacity in ASD and DR children than in ASD without DR; association of Coupling Efficiency and Maximal Respiratory Capacity with disruptive behaviors | Mitochondrial function is related to ASD symptoms and a potential mitochondrial therapeutic target in ASD |
12 | Öğütlü et al. (30) | Öğütlü/2020 | ADHD | mtDNA-cn | Peripheral blood | qPCR | ND1 | HBB | Higher mtDNA-cn in ADHD patients than in controls | Mitochondrial dysfunction is related to the etiopathogenesis of ADHD |
13 | Bam et al. (44) | Bam/2021 | ASD | mtDNA-cn, DNA methylation of PGC-1α and mtDNA deletion | Buccal cells | qPCR | ND1 | B2M | Higher mtDNA-cn in ASD patients than in control; methylation at the PGC-1α promoter can lead to mtDNA deletion and associated with high mtDNA-cn | Mitochondrial dysfunction in ASD |
14 | Öğütlü et al. (31) | Öğütlü/2021 | ADHD | mtDNA-cn | Peripheral blood | qPCR | ND1 | HBB | High mtDNA-cn in ADHD patients regardless of treatment | Mitochondrial dysfunction plays a role in pathophysiology of ADHD |
ASD, autism spectrum disorder; ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; mtDNA-cn, mitochondrial DNA copy number; qPCR, quantitative PCR; nDNA, nuclear DNA; ND1, NADH dehydrogenase 1; ND4, NADH dehydrogenase 4, CYTB, cytochrome b; HBB, beta-globin; PK; pyruvate kinase; APP, amyloid β A4 precursor protein; B2M, beta-2-microglobulin; NP, not provided.