Table 5.
Analytical Eco Scale assessment of the greenness of the presented and the reported methods using
The developed Method | The reported HPLC method [46] | ||
---|---|---|---|
Reagents | PPs* | Reagents | PPs* |
NH4Fe(SO4)2 (< 10 g) | 1 | DNFB (< 10 mL) | 8 |
NaHCO3 (< 10 g) | 1 | ||
Sodium salicylate (< 10 g) | 1 | KH2PO4, CH3COONa (< 10 g) | 0 |
HCl (< 10 mL) | 4 | ||
HNO3 (< 10 mL) | 4 | Methanol (10–100 mL) | 12 |
THF (< 10 mL) | 6 | ||
Ʃ | 6 | Ʃ | 31 |
Instruments | PPs | Instruments | PPs |
Spectrofluorometer | 0 | HPLC | 0 |
Occupational hazards | 0 | Occupational hazards | 3 |
Waste (˂10 mL, No treatment) | 6 | Waste (˂10 mL, No treatment) | 6 |
Ʃ | 6 | Ʃ | 9 |
Total | 12 | Total | 40 |
SCORE: 88 | SCORE: 60 |
*Calculations of penalty points (PPs) were performed per sample, DNFB: dinitrofluorobenzene, THF: tetrahydrofuran
Total PPs = ƩPPs, reagents + Ʃ PPs, instruments. SCORE = 100 – total PPs