Table 1.
Summary of representative TPD technologies related to different degradation pathways
| Pathway | TPD technologies | Target range | Composition | Advantages | Potential problems | Year | Refs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proteasome | PROTAC | Intracellular |
Small molecule/ biomacromolecule/ hybrid structure |
Relatively high selectivity; Acceptable oral bioavailability; Clear degradation mechanism; Catalytic and sub-stoichiometric |
Poor solubility for small-molecule PROTAC; Poor cell permeability; Poor PK properties; Limited target spectrum |
2001 | [11, 12] |
| Molecular glue | Intracellular | Small molecule | Acceptable oral bioavailability. | Difficult to design | 2010 | [13] | |
| SNIPER | Intracellular | Small molecule |
Simultaneous degradation of POIs and IAPs; High specificity |
E3 ligase IAPs dependently | 2010 | [14] | |
| HyT |
Intracellular/ extracellular |
Small molecule/ Small-molecule peptide conjugate |
Some hydrophobic tags are independent of E3 ligases and ubiquitination; Wide range of potential targets; |
Incomplete POIs degradation; Unclear degradation mechanism; Potential off-target effects |
2011 | [15] | |
| Trim-away | Intracellular | Antibody |
High specificity; Rapid degradation speed |
Need extra Trim21; Unable to recycle |
2017 | [16] | |
|
Endosome- lysosome |
LYTAC |
Extracellular/ membrane proteins |
Antibody |
Degrade extracellular and membrane proteins; High controllability |
Limited shuttle receptors; Potential immunogenicity; Non-catalytic; Low degradation efficiency |
2020 | [17, 18] |
| AbTAC | Membrane proteins | Bispecific antibody |
Degrade membrane proteins; High specificity |
Large molecular weight | 2021 | [19] | |
| GlueTAC |
Extracellular/ membrane proteins |
Nanobody-peptide conjugate |
High specificity; Sufficient membrane permeability by a cell penetration peptide |
Short half-life in vivo | 2021 | [20] | |
| Bispecific Aptamer Chimeras | Membrane proteins | Aptamer |
Easy to design and prepare; Good stability |
Low delivery efficacy; Short half-life in vivo |
2021 | [21] | |
| Sweeping antibody | Extracellular | Antibody | Allow recycling; | Required engineering for each target | 2013 | [22] | |
| Seldegs | IgG |
Antigen-Fc fusion proteins |
Degrade autoantibodies; Lower dose |
Required engineering for each target; Antigen selection |
2017 | [23] | |
| Autophagy-lysosome | CMA-based degrader |
Intracellular/ membrane proteins/aggregates |
Chimeric polypeptides. |
High specificity; High degradation efficacy |
Low delivery efficacy; Low stability; Limited therapeutic effects; |
2014 | [24] |
| AUTAC |
Intracellular/ damaged organelles |
Small molecule-poly(A) oligonucleotide conjugate |
A wide range of potential targets; Proteasome-independent |
Low degradation speed; Potential off-target effects; Dependent on K63 ubiquitination; |
2019 | [25] | |
| ATTAC |
Intracellular/ non-protein |
Small molecule |
A wide range of potential targets; Blood-brain barrier permeability; |
Difficult to design | 2019 | [26, 27] | |
| AUTOTAC |
Intracellular/ protein aggregates |
Small molecule | Degrade protein aggregates | Low degradation speed | 2022 | [28] | |
| Ribonuclease | RIBOTAC | RNA | Small molecule/small molecule-poly(A) oligonucleotide conjugate |
Expand targeted range to RNA; High degradation efficacy |
Difficulties in finding specific ligands for targeting RNA | 2018 | [29, 30] |
| ClpCP proteases | BacPROTAC | Bacterial proteins | Small molecule/small molecule-peptide conjugate | Expand the targeted range to bacterial protein | Low efficiency | 2022 | [8] |
Abbreviations: POI, Protein of interest; IAPs, Inhibitor of apoptosis protein; HyT, Hydrophobic Tag; PROTAC, Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras; TPD, Targeted protein degradation; PK, Pharmacokinetics; SNIPER, Specific and Non-genetic IAP-dependent Protein Erasers; Trim21, Tripartite motif-containing protein 21; LYTAC, Lysosome-targeting chimeras; AbTAC, Antibody-based PROTAC; IgG, immunoglobulin G; CMA, Chaperone mediated autophagy; AUTAC, Autophagy-targeting chimera; ATTAC, Autophagy-tethering compounds; AUTOTAC, AUTOphagy-TArgeting Chimera; RIBOTAC, Ribonuclease targeting chimera