Table 2.
Dynamic change of risk prediction model scores at different on-treatment timepoints
Models | Before AVT (n=660) | On-treatment timepoints |
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year 2.5 (n=660) | Year 3 (n=640) | Year 3.5 (n=622) | Year 4 (n=603) | Year 4.5 (n=589) | Year 5 (n=562) | |||
Untreated models without the cirrhosis variable | ||||||||
REACH-B | 10.14±2.48 | 5.93±2.14 | 5.87±2.07 | 6.13±2.12 | 6.07±2.05 | 5.98±2.03 | 5.97±2.00 | |
NGM1 | 8.32±2.48 | 6.66±2.51 | 6.69±2.39 | 6.77±2.45 | 6.94±2.47 | 6.60±2.37 | 6.73±2.34 | |
NGM2 | 11.20±2.67 | 7.87±3.41 | 7.81±3.17 | 7.95±3.31 | 8.13±3.34 | 7.43±3.08 | 7.51±2.97 | |
Untreated models with the cirrhosis variable | ||||||||
GAG-HCC | 92.92±22.05 | 75.88±22.43 | 76.49±21.69 | 76.55±21.57 | 76.88±21.82 | 76.20±21.13 | 74.73±20.98 | |
Treated or mixed models without the cirrhosis variable | ||||||||
mREACH-BI | 8.03±2.18 | 6.55±2.34 | 6.38±2.23 | 6.60±2.26 | 6.60±2.25 | 6.47±2.21 | 6.49±2.19 | |
mREACH-BII | 9.48±2.64 | 7.23±2.82 | 6.98±2.68 | 7.17±2.71 | 7.20±2.69 | 7.02±2.63 | 7.07±2.60 | |
LSM-HCC | 16.36±7.41 | 9.02±8.13 | 8.41±7.98 | 8.45±7.98 | 8.56±7.76 | 8.57±7.89 | 8.85±7.84 | |
SAGE-B | 7.04±3.47 | 5.30±3.31 | 5.20±3.15 | 5.23±3.15 | 5.37±3.08 | 5.44±3.11 | 5.56±3.00 | |
mPAGE-B | 10.33±3.24 | 9.98±3.18 | 10.08±3.07 | 10.00±2.99 | 10.22±3.05 | 10.15±2.98 | 10.36±2.93 | |
PAGE-B | 14.49±4.57 | 14.00±4.88 | 14.03±4.78 | 13.79±4.71 | 14.09±4.77 | 13.90±4.72 | 14.22±4.69 | |
aMAP | 60.36±7.56 | 58.74±7.52 | 58.58±7.44 | 58.47±7.44 | 58.51±7.43 | 58.43±7.37 | 58.79±7.30 | |
Treated or mixed models with the cirrhosis variable | ||||||||
AASL-HCC | 13.25±6.69 | 11.37±6.51 | 11.60±6.43 | 11.46±6.37 | 11.67±6.52 | 11.41±6.29 | 10.93±6.19 | |
CAMD | 10.10±5.14 | 9.30±5.21 | 9.57±5.11 | 9.49±5.07 | 9.70 ±5.22 | 9.60±5.02 | 9.40±4.94 | |
REAL-B | 5.11±2.13 | 4.57±2.07 | 4.64±2.04 | 4.57±1.97 | 4.69±2.05 | 4.59±1.96 | 4.54±1.91 | |
CU-HCC | 16.12±11.15 | 8.68±8.51 | 8.74±8.54 | 8.50±8.18 | 8.52±8.49 | 8.30±8.29 | 7.36±8.18 | |
RWS-HCC | 4.57±2.07 | 3.26±1.86 | 3.28±1.80 | 3.22±1.74 | 3.17±1.74 | 3.14±1.73 | 2.91±1.74 | |
CAGE-B | 7.32±3.91 | 6.66±3.56 | 6.69±3.46 | 6.70±3.44 | 6.86±3.41 | 6.90±3.43 | 7.03±3.34 |
Model scores were expressed as mean±standard deviation.
AVT, antiviral treatment; HCC, hepatocellular carcinoma; LSM, liver stiffness measurement.