Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 26;18(7):e0282286. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0282286

Table 1. Baseline characteristics of all included studies.

First author Country Study design Sample size(E/C) Age(years) Group Follow-up(month) SER,D(E/C) Axial Length, mm(E/C) Axial Length Measurements
Ji N2022 China RE 46/49 9.96±1.75/10.14±1.84 SA/OK 12 H:-3.78±1.21/-4.01±1.13 H: 24.71±0.89/24.80±0.81 IOL master
L: -2.18±1.08/-1.94±1.33 L:24.01±0.84/24.08±1.32
Jiang J2018 China Non-RCT 80/80 11.50±2.30/12.10±2.10 SA/OK 18 -2.85±0.54/-2.75±0.52 23.90±1.30/23.93±1.07 -
Ren QL2017 China RCT 50/50 11.96±2.58 SA/OK 12 -3.16±0.28/-3.08±0.11 24.32±1.16/24.28±1.32 -
Zhao Q2021 China RCT 20/20 9.65±1.53/11.00±1.17 SA/OK 6,12 -1.98±0.45/-2.75±0.46 24.17±0.68/24.42±0.48 LS-900
Zhao Q2022 China RCT 20/21 10.9±1.29/11.00±1.17 AOK/OK 6,13 -2.85±0.45/-2.75±0.46 24.56±0.39/24.42±0.48 LS-900
Tan Q2020 China RCT 29/30 9.20±1.00/9.10±1.20 AOK/OK 6,12 -2.65±0.92/-2.84±0.96 24.43±0.62/24.43±0.81 IOL master
Tan Q2022 China RCT 34/35 9.20±1.00/9.10±1.20 AOK/OK 6,12,24 -2.76±0.88/-2.83±1.01 24.56±0.71/24.50±0.92 IOL master
Chen Z2019 China RE 28/29 7.50±1.20/8.30±1.50 AOK/OK 12 -2.70±1.10/-2.50±0.94 24.80±0.87/24.53±0.61 IOL master
Chen Z2021 China RE 37/36 8.90±1.40/8.80±1.21 AOK/OK 12,24 -2.85±1.08/-2.38±1.10 24.49±0.96/24.26±0.90 IOL master
Kinoshita N2018 Japan RCT 20/20 10.87±1.38/10.40±1.86 AOK/OK 12 − 2.81±1.43/− 2.95±1.43 24.73±0.58/24.95±0.92 IOL master
Kinoshita N2020 Japan RCT 38/35 10.33±1.59/10.37±1.65 AOK/OK 24 -2.60±1.29/-2.72±1.31 24.69±0.58/24.86±0.81 IOL master
Vincent J2020 China RCT 25/38 8.90±1.20/9.10±1.10 AOK/OK 6 -2.38±0.81/-2.58±0.91 24.38±0.62/24.44±0.84 IOL master
Tang WT2020 China RCT L: 20/22 H: 43/41 11.05±2.13 AOK/OK 12 L:-2.56±1.15/-2.59±1.12 L:23.72±0.31/23.70±0.29 IOL master
H:-4.90±1.16/-4.92±1.21 H:24.69±0.34/24.71±0.37
Niu YL2019 China Non-RCT 80/72 13.73±2.52/13.61±2.41 AOK/OK 12 -1.40±0.25/-1.38±0.23 23.58±3.39/23.61±3.42 IOL master
Luo Y2021 China Non-RCT 60/60 10.02±2.35/10.77±1.91 AOK/OK 12 -3.26±1.35/-3.18±1.32 25.12±0.81/25.01±0.79 IOL master