Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 20;12:251. Originally published 2023 Mar 8. [Version 2] doi: 10.12688/f1000research.131659.2

Table 1. Characteristics of the included studies.

Author, Year Continent Diagnosis Risk of bias N Prevalence (%) Type of dental health care personnel
Macdonald et al. 1988 NA SR L 2464 8.69 DA
Osborn et al. 1990 NA SR M 394 6.85 DA
Conrad et al. 1991 NA V L 20 0.00 DA
Conrad et al. 1992 NA V M 16 0.00 DA
Conrad et al. 1993 NA V L 16 0.00 DA
Nakladalova et al. 1995 Eu NC M 120 3.33 DA
Liss et al. 1995 NA SR M 1058 10.21 DA
Scoggins and Campbell 1995 NA SR M 79 5.06 DA
Rice et al. 1996 NA PE L 45 11.11 Mixed
Akesson et al. 1999 Eu PE L 84 7.14 Mixed
Lalumandier et al. 2000 NA SR L 5115 25.45 Mixed
Hamann et al. 2001 NA NC L 1079 4.82 D
Anton et al. 2002 NA NC L 89 8.99 DA
Werner et al. 2002 NA NC L 305 5.57 DA
Mamatha et al. 2005 Asia SR L 300 32.00 D
Werner et al. 2005 NA NC L 232 0.43 D
Werner et al. 2005b NA SR L 111 0.90 DA
Cherniack et al. 2006 NA PE L 160 12.50 DA
Greathouse et al. 2009 NA NC L 35 25.71 DA
Shaffer et al. 2012 NA NC L 55 10.91 DA
Haghighat et al. 2012 Asia PE L 240 16.67 D
Borhan et al. 2013 Asia NC L 40 17.50 D
Khan et al. 2014 Asia SR L 417 10.31 D
Pai et al. 2014 Asia SR L 210 20.00 D
Munirah et al. 2014 Asia SR M 99 21.21 D
Hodacova et al. 2015 Eu SR M 575 14.61 D
Nor Rasid et al. 2016 Asia SR L 95 38.95 DA
Ehsan et al. 2016 Asia PE L 103 15.53 D
Prasad et al. 2017 Asia SR L 100 86.00 D
Jaoude et al. 2017 Asia SR L 314 7.64 D
De JeSUS et al. 2018 SA SR L 286 13.29 D
Inbasekharan et al. 2018 Asia SR L 120 25.83 D
Alhusain et al. 2019 Asia SR L 223 30.49 D
Meisha et al. 2019 Asia SR L 234 9.40 D
Al Muraikhi et al. 2020 Asia SR L 66 24.24 D
Harris et al. 2020 NA SR L 647 18.39 DA
Berdouses et al. 2020 Eu SR L 1500 8.27 D
Maghsoudipour et al. 2021 Asia NC L 106 17.92 D

NA: North America; SA: South America; Eu: Europe; SR: self-reported; NC: Nerve conduction; PE: Physical examination; V: Vibrometry; DA: Dental Auxilaries; D: Dentists/dental students; N: sample size; Mixed: Dental Auxiliaries or Dentists/dental students.