Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 28;2023(7):CD007546. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007546.pub3
Source Search strategy Hits retrieved
Dementia Register (CRSO)
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
"physical restraint" OR "physical restraints" OR bedrail OR bedrails OR bedchair OR bedchairs OR "containment measure" OR "containment measures" Feb 2017: 2
Mar 2018: 0
Dec 2018: 0
Nov 2019: 3
Oct 2020: 4
Oct 2021: 11
Aug 2022: 9
1. CENTRAL (The Cochrane Library) http://crso.cochrane.org/SearchSimple.php
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
#1 “physical restraint*”
#2 bedrail*
#3 bedchair*
#4 “containment measure*”
#5¬ #1 or #2 or #3 or #4
#6 elderly
#7 “old people”
#8 geriatric*
#9 aged
#10 “nursing home*”
#11 “care home*”
#12 “geriatric care”
#13 “residential facit*”
#14¬ #6 or #7 or #8 or #9 or #10 or #12 or #13
#15¬ #5 and #14
#16¬ #15 [clinical trials]
Feb 2017: 27
Mar 2018: 7
Dec 2018: 4
Nov 2019: 29
Oct 2020: 18
Oct 2021: 17
Aug 2022: 17
2. MEDLINE (Ovid SP)
Ovid MEDLINE(R) Epub Ahead of Print, In‐Process & Other Non‐Indexed Citations, Ovid MEDLINE(R) Daily, Ovid MEDLINE and Versions(R)
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
1 physical restraint*.mp.
2 (bedrail* or "bed rail*").mp.
3 (bedchair* or "bed chair*").mp.
4 "containment measure*".mp.
5 exp Restraint, Physical/
6 Education, Nursing/
7 6 or 4 or 1 or 3 or 2 or 5
8 elderly.mp.
9 ("old people" or "old person*").mp.
10 geriatric*.mp.
11 aged.mp.
12 ("nursing home*" or nursinghome).mp.
13 "care home*".mp.
14 ("residential home*" or "residential facilit*").mp.
15 Aged/
16 Residential Facilities/
17 11 or 9 or 12 or 15 or 14 or 8 or 16 or 10 or 13
18 7 and 17
19 randomized controlled trial.pt.
20 controlled clinical trial.pt.
21 randomi?ed.ab.
22 randomly.ab.
23 trial.ab.
24 groups.ab.
25 22 or 21 or 24 or 23 or 19 or 20
26 (animals not (humans and animals)).sh.
27 25 not 26
28 27 and 18
Feb 2017: 44
Mar 2018: 35
Dec 2018: 31
Nov 2019: 72
Oct 2020: 64
Oct 2021: 79
Aug 2022: 72
3. EMBASE via OVID
1974 to present
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
1 Physical restraint*.mp.
2 bedrail*.mp.
3 bedchair*.mp.
4 Containment measure*.mp.
5 1 or 2 or 3 or 4
6 elderly.mp.
7 old people.mp.
8 geriatric*.mp.
9 aged.mp.
10 nursing home.mp.
11 care home.mp.
12 geriatric care.mp.
13 residential facility*.mp.
14 6 or 7 or 8 or 9 or 10 or 11 or 12 or 13
15 randomized controlled trial.mp.
16 controlled clinical trial.mp.
17 randomized.mp.
18 groups.mp.
19 15 or 16 or 17 or 18
20 5 and 14 and 19
Feb 2017: 10
Mar 2018: 19
Dec 2018: 13
Nov 2019: 21
Oct 2020: 26
Oct 2021: 67
Aug 2022: 86
4. PsycINFO via OVID
1806 to present
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
1 Physical restraint*.mp.
2 bedrail*.mp.
3 "bed rail*".mp.
4 (bedchair* or "bed chair*").mp.
5 Containment measure*.mp.
6 4 or 1 or 3 or 2 or 5
7 exp Physical Restraint/
8 6 or 7
9 elderly.mp.
10 ("old people" or "old person*").mp.
11 geriatric*.mp.
12 aged.mp.
13 ("nursing home*" or nursinghome).mp.
14 "care home*".mp.
15 ("residential home*" or "residential facilit*").mp.
16 exp Residential Care Institutions/
17 11 or 9 or 12 or 15 or 14 or 10 or 13 or 16
18 exp Clinical Trials/
19 randomized controlled trial.mp.
20 controlled clinical trial.mp.
21 randomized.mp.
22 groups.mp.
23 22 or 21 or 18 or 19 or 20
24 8 and 17 and 23
Feb 2017: 30
Mar 2018: 3
Dec 2018: 2
Nov 2019: 7
Oct 2020: 13
Oct 2021: 14
Aug 2022: 11
5. CINAHL (EBSCOhost)
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
S1¬ TX physical restraint*
S2¬ TX bedrail*
S3¬ TX bedchair*
S4¬ TX “containment measure*”
S5¬ S1 OR S2 OR S3 OR S4
S6¬ TX elderly
S7¬ TX “old people” or “old person*”
S8¬ TX geriatric*
S9¬ TX aged
S10¬ TX “nursing home*” or nursinghome
S11¬ TX “care home*”
S12¬ TX “residential home*” or “residential facility*”
S13¬ S6 or S7 or S8 or S9 or S10 or S11 or S12
S14¬ S5 and S13
S15¬ TX “randomized controlled trial”
S16¬ TX “controlled clinical trial”
S17¬ AB random*
S18¬ AB trial
S19¬ AB groups
S20¬ S15 or S16 or S17 or S18 or S19
S21 S14 and S20
Feb 2017: 67
Mar 2018: 14
Dec 2018: 16
Nov 2019: 26
Oct 2020: 22
Oct 2021: 13
Aug 2022: 10
6. Clarivate Web of Science – all databases [includes: Web of Science (1945‐present); BIOSIS Previews (1926‐present); MEDLINE (1950‐present); Journal Citation Reports]
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
TOPIC: ("physical restraint*" OR bedrail* OR bedchair* OR "containment measure*") AND TOPIC: (elderly OR "Old people" OR geriatric* OR aged OR "nursing home" Or "care home" OR "geriatric care" Or "residential facilit*") AND TOPIC: ("randomized controlled trial" OR "controlled clinical trial" OR randomized OR groups) Feb 2017: 129
Mar 2018: 23
Dec 2018: 17
Nov 2019: 29
Oct 2020: 30
Oct 2021: 71
Aug 2022: 119
7. LILACS (BIREME)
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
(“physical restraint*” AND (elderly OR geriatr$)) Feb 2017: 0
Mar 2018: 0
Dec 2018: 0
Nov 2019: 10
Oct 2020: 6
Oct 2021: 1
Aug 2022: 1
8. ClinicalTrials.gov
(www.clinicaltrials.gov)
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
elderly OR geriatr$ | “physical restraint*” | Feb 2017: 2
Mar 2018:0
Dec 2018: 6
Nov 2019: 7
Oct 2020: 1
Oct 2021: 1
Aug 2022: 0
9. ICTRP
[Date of most recent search: 3 August 2022]
elderly OR geriatr* AND physical restraint* Feb 2017: 0
Mar 2018: 0
Dec 2018: 0
Nov 2019: 0
Oct 2020: 0
Oct 2021: 0
Aug 2022: 0
TOTAL before de‐duplication Feb 2017: 307
Mar 2018: 101
Dec 2018: 89
Nov 2019: 204
Oct 2020: 184
Oct 2021: 274
Aug 2022: 325
TOTAL: 1484
TOTAL after de‐duplication Feb 2017:
258
Mar 2018: 74
Dec 2018: 64
Nov 2019: 150
Oct 2020: 138
Oct 2021: 206
Aug 2022: 233
TOTAL: 1123
TOTAL after first assessment by Cochrane Information Specialist Feb 2017: 44
Mar 2018: 12
Dec 2018: 20
TOTAL: 76