Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 10;16(7):988. doi: 10.3390/ph16070988

Table 2.

Quality assessment of the included studies using SYRCLE’s risk of bias tool for animal studies.

Study Selection Bias Performance Bias Detection
Bias
Attrition Bias Reporting Bias Other
Was the Allocation Sequence Adequately Generated and Applied? Were the Groups Similar at Baseline or Were They Adjusted for Confounders in the
Analysis?
Was the Allocation Adequately Concealed? Were the Animals Randomly Housed during the Experiment? Were the Caregivers and/or Investigators Blinded from Knowledge of Which Intervention Each Animal Received during the Experiment? Were Animals Selected at Random for Outcome Assessment? Was the Outcome Assessor
Blinded?
Were Incomplete Outcome Data Adequately Addressed? Are Reports of the Study Free of Selective Outcome Reporting? Was the Study Apparently Free of Other Problems that could Result in High Risk of Bias?
Makino et al. [31] Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Makino et al. [32] Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Makino et al. [33] Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Makino et al. [34] Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear No No Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Sakurai et al. [35] Yes Yes Unclear Unclear Unclear No Unclear Yes Yes Yes