Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Jul 30.
Published before final editing as: IEEE J Biomed Health Inform. 2023 Jan 30;PP:10.1109/JBHI.2023.3240508. doi: 10.1109/JBHI.2023.3240508

TABLE II.

Prediction Performances of Prediction Methods in Discovery Dataset


Model Added Covariate A+B+Imaging A+Imaging Imaging only

CPM M1. SC(+) + Covariate 0.46 (2.0e-6) 0.46 (1.6e-6) 0.32 (1.3e-3)
M2. SC(-) + Covariate 0.50 (2.1e-7) 0.44 (7.0e-6) 0.28 (5.2e-3)
M3. SC(+, -) + Covariate 0.56 (2.7e-9) 0.53 (2.9e-8) 0.40 (4.7e-5)
M4. FC(+) + Covariate 0.59 (3.5e-10) 0.58 (6.5e-10) 0.35 (4.8e-4)
M5. FC(-) + Covariate 0.52 (4.6e-8) 0.51 (1.3e-7) 0.45 (3.5e-6)
M6. FC(+, -) + Covariate 0.59 (2.3e-10) 0.59 (3.9e-10) 0.54 (1.6e-8)
M7. SC(+) + FC(+) + Covariate 0.46 (2.0e-6) 0.37 (1.9e-4) 0.24 (1.8e-2)
M8. SC(-) + FC(-) + Covariate 0.58 (4.0e-10) 0.58 (7.4e-10) 0.50 (2.1e-7)
M9. SC(+,-) + FC(+,-) + Covariate 0.61 (2.8e-11) 0.55 (6.5e-9) 0.53 (1.9e-8)

SVR M3. SC(+, -) + Covariate 0.46 (1.2e-6) 0.41 (2.3e-5) 0.30 (1.8e-3)
M6. FC(+, -) + Covariate 0.48 (4.7e-7) 0.47 (5.0e-7) 0.43 (7.5e-6)
M9. SC(+,-) + FC(+,-) + Covariate 0.57 (4.2e-10) 0.51 (4.0e-8) 0.47 (5.9e-7)

Elastic net M3. SC(+, -) + Covariate 0.47 (9.7e-4) 0.44 (6.6e-6) 0.30 (1.9e-3)
M6. FC(+, -) + Covariate 0.52 (6.5e-8) 0.45 (1.6e-6) 0.39 (4.1e-5)
M9. SC(+,-) + FC(+,-) + Covariate 0.56 (4.0e-9) 0.38 (NS) 0.32 (8.9e-4)

LASSO M3. SC(+, -) + Covariate 0.47 (7.8e-7) 0.41 (1.6e-5) 0.31 (1.6e-3)
M6. FC(+, -) + Covariate 0.50 (1.3e-7) 0.51 (4.1e-8) 0.50 (1.3e-7)
M9. SC(+,-) +FC(+,-) + Covariate 0.50 (1.3e-7) 0.51 (4.0e-8) 0.50 (1.2e-7)

PLSR M3. SC(+, -) + Covariate 0.51 (7.2e-8) 0.50 (2.3e-7) 0.37 (2.0e-4)
M6. FC(+, -) + Covariate 0.58 (6.5e-11) 0.55 (2.7e-11) 0.52 (3.5e-8)
M9. SC(+,-) + FC(+,-) + Covariate 0.59 (6.4e-11) 0.58 (2.0e-11) 0.53 (2.9e-8)

Correlation between predicted and observed scores (corresponding p-value). Bolded values correspond to the highest correlation in their respective models. Values in red correspond to the highest correlation when added the same covariate among five models. A – Demographic; B – HIV Measure; + = positive; - = negative; SC = structural connectivity; FC = functional connectivity; NS= not significant.