Table 5.
Studies reporting smoking as a risk factor
Study type | n | Comparison | Association with ILD | Adjusted for one or more baseline variables? | Grading | |
Juge et al15 | Retrospective, multicentre cohort | 1234 | Ever smoker vs never smoker | p=0.53 | Age, sex, country of origin | 4 |
Li et al25 | Retrospective, longitudinal, single-centre cohort | 923 | Ever smoker vs never smoker | OR 1.070 (95% CI 0.663 to 1.726); p=0.783 | Age, sex, smoking, RA duration and severity, ACPA, RF | 4 |
Paulin et al36 | Prospective, single-centre cohort | 118 | Ever smoker vs never smoker | OR 5.85 (95% CI 2.12 to 16.09); p=0.001 | Extra-articular manifestations, disease activity | 3 |
Wang and Du27 | Retrospective, single-centre cohort | 544 | Current smokers vs ex/never smokers | OR=1.71 (95% CI 0.67 to 4.38); p=0.263 | Age, sex, steroid use, ACPA, RF, disease duration, HBsAg, Tripterygium wilfordii use | 3 |
Doyle et al32 | Prospective cohort, from two centres | 189 | Pack-years | p<0.1 | No | 3 |
Wickrematilake51 | Retrospective, single-centre cohort | 384 | Ever smoker vs never smoker | p<0.0001 | No | 3 |
Salaffi et al30 | Retrospective, single-centre cohort | 151 | Current smoker vs ex/never smoker | p=0.03 | No | 3 |
Furukawa et al33 | Prospective, single-centre cohort | 450 | Ever smoker vs never smoker | p=0.2673 | No | 2 |
Yin et al37 | Retrospective, single-centre cohort | 285 | Not stated | p=0.3 | No | 2 |
Grading was performed using Oxford criteria as detailed in the methods.
The remaining studies all reported unadjusted analyses with varying degrees of association (or no association) of smoking with ILD.27 30 32 33 37 51
ACPA, anticitrullinated protein antibodies; HBsAg, hepatitis B surface antigen; ILD, interstitial lung disease; RA, rheumatoid arthritis; RF, rheumatoid factor.