Skip to main content
. 2023 Apr 10;109(5):1497–1508. doi: 10.1097/JS9.0000000000000346

Table 1.

Main characteristics of the included studies in the systematic review.

First author, year, reference Study type Mean follow-up, (range) N Female% (N) Mean age (years) (range) Mean BMI, kg/m2 (range) Primary or revision Length BP limb8 Duration (min)
Scavone et al., 20209 Retro 60 months 953 71.7% (684) 41.8 49.4 Both 180–240 100±16 (primary) 118±22 (revision)
Bashah et al., 202010 Retro 3.8±1.4 years 49 85.7% (42) 37.83±9.36 43.6±7.4 Revision 150–200 N/A
Lessing et al., 202011 Retro 2 years 57 63.1% (36) 47.7±10.8 42.8±7.0 Revision N/A N/A
Neuberg et al., 202012 Retro 92 months (76–111) 163 N/A 41±11.4 41.2±6.5 Both 150 N/A
Liagre et al., 201913 Retro 90 days 2780 85% (39) 45 (26–64) 41.5 (31–55) Both N/A N/A
Sohrabi Maralani et al., 202114 Retro 5 years N/A N/A 39.73±11.50 44.79±6.07 N/A N/A N/A
Debs et al., 202015 Retro 55 months (8–144) 77 81.8% (63) 45.3±14.8 40.1 (29–57) Revision only 150 42.0±8.0
Younis et al., 202016 Retro 6 months 9 44.4% (4) 41±11 (23–57) 44±8 Both N/A N/A
Musella et al., 201717 Retro 5 years 2678 70.4% (1885) 42.2±3.8 45.39±3.63 Both 165–260 86.6±36.5 (primary) 109.3±24.8 (revision)
Lessing et al., 201718 Retro 12 months 407 62.4% (254) 4 1.8±1 2.05 41.7±5.77 Both 200 N/A
Nevo et al., 202119 Retro 21 months 21 76% (16) 43.2±12.1 39.7±5.9 Revision only 200 N/A
Musella et al., 201920 Retro 20.8 months (6–156) 196 N/A 46.1±10.5 45.1±7 Revision only 226 N/A
Noun et al., 201821 Prosp 12 months 21 52.3% (11) 39±12 (18–65) 42.9±6.5 Revision only N/A N/A
Nagliati et al., 201922 Prosp 2 years 8 N/A N/A N/A Both N/A N/A
Poublon et al., 202023 Retro 3 years 185 75.5% (139) 46±9.0 40.9 (36–45) Revision only 150–250 72 (56–95)
Meydan et al., 201724 Retro 6 months 154 72.1% (111) 47.06 41.76 Both 150–200 N/A
Bolckmans et al., 201925 Prosp 9 years 526 89.3% (25) N/A N/A Primary only 200 N/A
Alkhalifah et al., 201826 Retro 10 years 1731 70% (1212) 33.8±10.4 40.4±7.7 Primary only 150–250 124.6±38.8
Chansaenroj et al., 201727 Retro N/A 26 61.5% (16) 35.9±8.8 39.3±8.9 Revision only N/A 180.2±58.7
Apers et al., 201828 Prosp 3 years 287 85.4% (245) 44 (19–69) 42 (32–76) Primary only 150–250 50 (25-120)
Almalki et al., 201829 Retro 5 years 81 74% (60) 38.7±9.8 37.8±9.6 Revision only N/A 167.7±55.8
Genser et al., 201630 Retro 8 years and 9 months 2321 N/A 41 (26–63) N/A Both N/A N/A
de la Cruz et al., 202031 Retro 3 years 42 N/A N/A 43.4±9.2 Revision only 200 N/A
Parmar et al., 201832 Retro 6 months to 12 years 12 807 N/A 41.2 46.6 N/A N/A 123±39
Soong et al., 201933 Retro 12 months 940 62.3% (586) 40.6 40 Primary only 400 142
Navarrete et al., 201834 Prosp 12 months 100 64% (64) 40.5±12.4 44.8±12.1 Primary only N/A 69±4.62
Lo et al., 202035 Retro 12 months 73 61% (39) 40.8 42.5 Primary only N/A 117
Parmar et al., 202036 Retro 32.7 months (6–84) 376 67.7% (254) 44.3 29.2 N/A 120 89.5 (49–150)
Khalaj et al., 202037 Retro 12 months 548 85% (457) 39.5 46 Primary only 160–200 71.8
Salama et al., 201638 Prosp 12 months 39 N/A 38.7 39.7 Revision only 180 145±29 (125–235)
Taha et al. 201739 Retro 6–36 months 1520 62.7% (953) 37.2±11.4 46.8±6.6 Both 150–300 57
AlSabah et al., 201840 Retro 12 months 31 89.7% (28) 41.4±10.2 42.6±5.8 Revision only 175–200 118.2±53.1
Pujol Rafols et al., 201841 Retro 12–60 months 191 89.5% (171) 40.6±11.2 39.8±6.9 Revision only 150–250 N/A
Beaupel et al., 20174 Retro 24.5 (4–108) 17 76.5% (13) 48 (23–62) 51 (38–70) Both 150–200 N/A
Carbajo et al., 200542 Retro 2 years 209 82% (172) 41 (14–66) 48 (39–86) Both 200 93 (70–150)
Noun et al., 201243 Retro 60 months 1000 66.1% (661) 33.15 42.5 Both 150 89 (primary) 144 (revision)
Piazza et al., 201544 Retro 5 years 48 82% 38 43.4 Revision only 180–240 N/A
Chevallier et al., 201545 Retro 7 years 1000 71.2% (712) 41.8 45.7 Both 200 N/A
Ghosh et al., 201746 Retro 12 months 74 91% (67) 48.3 46 Revision only 150 72.7
Abdallah et al., 202247 Retro 12 months 80 77.5% (62) 41 50.9 Primary only 200 (170–300) N/A
Plamper et al., 201748 Retro N/A 169 71.6% (121) N/A 54.1% Primary only N/A N/A
Parmar et al., 201649 Retro 2 years 125 68.8% (86) 45 48.1 Primary only N/A 92.4
Bruzzi et al., 201550 Retro 5 years 126 79% (99) 50±10 47 Revision only N/A 110
Disse et al., 201451 Retro 21.4 months 20 N/A 49.5 40.1 Primary only N/A 105
Johnson et al., 20078 Retro N/A 32 N/A N/A N/A Primary only N/A N/A
Beargeat et al., 201752 Retro N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
Piazza et al., 201153 Retro 2 197 75% (148) 37.9 52.9 N/A N/A 120
Noun et al., 200754 Retro N/A 126 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A
Kular et al., 201455 Retro 6 years 1054 67.5% (712 ) 38.4 43.2 N/A 200 52
Musella et al., 201456 Retro 12–60 months 974 51.2% (499) 39.4 48±4.58 Both 224.6±23.2 95±51.6
Wang et al., 200557 Retro Up to 36 months 423 79% (336) 30.8 44.2 Both 200 95±41.5
Docimo et al., 202258 Retro 1 month 279 81.7% (228) 46.1 (11.04) 44.5±7.7 Primary N/A N/A
Rayman et al., 202159 Retro review 25.5 months (8–60) 144 74.3% (107) 42.4±10.5 40.6±5.9 Revision only N/A N/A
Rutledge and Walsh, 200560 Prosp 38.7 months (1.0–74.4) 2410 85% (2049) 39 (14–78) 46±7 (34–74) Both N/A 37.5
Almuhanna et al., 202161 Retro N/A 2223 70.2% (1560) 35.3±11.4 (14–71 ) 40.2±11.9 N/A N/A N/A
Goel et al., 202162 Retro 3 years 3187 53.8% (1712) 43.3±12.2 44.5±7.9 Both N/A N/A
Garcia-Caballero et al., 200563 Case report N/A 1 1 36 43 Primary only N/A N/A

BP limb, biliopancreatic limb, Retro, retrospective study ; Prosp, prospective study.