Skip to main content
. 2023 Jul 20;62:102100. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2023.102100

Table 3.

The results of meta-analysis for cough score change (WMD).

Score system Study
No. of placebo
No. of treatment
Pooled score change
P-value Certainty in pooled estimates
(n) (n) (n) (95% CI)
P2X3 antagonist
 LCQ 7 771 1510 1.637 (0.887, 2.387) <0.001 High
 Awake cough frequency (c/h) 4 162 352 −15.476 (−28.358, −2.594) 0.019 Moderate
 Night-time cough frequency (c/h) 4 119 117 −1.782 (−5.813, 2.248) 0.386 Moderate
 24 h cough frequency (c/h) 5 182 370 −11.042 (−21.306, −0.778) 0.035 Moderate
 Cough severity VAS (mm) 8 761 1069 −11.075 (−17.496, −5.914) <0.001 High
 Urge to cough VAS (mm) 3 107 238 −13.16 (−21.938, −4.381) 0.003 Moderate
 CSD total score 6 741 1381 −1.625 (−3.098, −0.151) 0.031 Moderate
TRP modulator
 LCQ 2 37 35 −0.285 (−2.353, 1.783) 0.787 Moderate
 Day-time cough frequency (c/h) 2 38 38 5.244 (3.405, 7.082) <0.001 Moderate
 24 h cough frequency (c/h) 2 41 41 2.597 (0.393, 4.800) 0.021 Moderate
 Cough severity VAS (mm) 2 38 36 5.337 (3.445, 7.229) <0.001 Moderate
 Urge to cough VAS (mm) 3 57 54 0.159 (−3.583, 3.901) 0.933 Moderate
GABA modulator
 LCQ 2 54 52 1.347 (0.466, 2.229) 0.003 Moderate
 24 h cough frequency (c/h) 2 54 52 −12.929 (−33.858, 8.000) 0.226 Low
 Cough severity VAS (mm) 2 52 48 −7.843 (−13.023, −2.663) 0.003 Moderate
Macrolide
 LCQ 2 37 37 1.589 (0.245, 2.932) 0.02 Moderate

Abbreviations: WMD, weighted mean difference; CI, confidence interval; LCQ, leicester cough questionnaire; VAS, visual analogue score; CSD, cough severity diary.

Some medicines and outcomes were not available for meta-analysis due to the limited number of literatures.

Pooled score change, the absolute difference between the mean value in medication and placebo.

The certainty in pooled estimate was evaluated by GRADE.