Table 3.
Error data captured by the automated methods and how it is being used
| Automated search methods identifying all errors | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper | Descriptive information about error timings | Background error rate | Intervention error rate | Further relevant information |
| Used unique method of Koppel et al46 | ||||
| Koppel et al46 | Orders stopped within 30 min were most likely to be deemed inappropriate | Not specified | No intervention | |
| Method utilizing the descriptive discontinuation option native to the CPOE system (eg, “void,” “Error—erroneous entry”) | ||||
| Kannampallil et al54 | Not specified | 490 “voids” per 100 000 orders (0.49%) | No intervention | Originally reported as per 1000 orders |
| Abraham et al41 | Not specified | 210 “voids” per 100 000 orders (0.21%) | No intervention | Originally reported as per 1000 orders |
| Hickman et al55 | Not specified | 450 “errors” per 100 000 orders (0.45%) | No intervention | Originally reported as per 1000 orders |
| Abraham et al26 | Median time from medication ordering to its voiding was 0.38 h | Not specified | No intervention | Primarily a qualitative paper |
| Automated search methods identifying WPOE specifically | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paper | Descriptive information about error timings | Background error rate | Intervention error rate | Further relevant information |
| Used unique method of Levin et al48 | ||||
| Levin et al48 |
|
64 per 100 000 | No intervention | Originally reported as 0.064% |
| Used RAR method of Adelman et al22 | ||||
| Adelman et al22 | Mean time to retraction of 1 min and 18 s | 58 per 100 000 orders |
|
|
| Green et al23 | Not specified | 202 per 100 000 orders |
|
|
| Adelman et al43 | Not specified | 45 per 100 000 orders | 29 per 100 000 orders | WPOE calculated by dividing RAR events by PPV of RAR method by review team |
| Lombardi et al54 | Not specified | 6.125 “events” per week | 4 “events” per week | Intervention was a patient ID-reentry function |
| Adelman et al51 | Not specified |
|
No intervention | WPOE calculated by dividing RAR events by PPV of RAR method by review team |
| Salmasian et al53 | Not specified | 142 per 100 000 orders | 101 per 100 000 orders |
|
| Kern-Goldberger et al51 | Not specified |
|
No intervention | WPOE calculated by dividing RAR events by PPV of RAR method by review team |
| Udeh et al52 | Not specified | 27.8 per 100 000 orders | 21.1 per 100 000 orders | WPOE calculated by dividing RAR events by PPV of RAR method by review team |
| Unique method of Galanter et al49 coupled with RAR method of Adelman et al22 | ||||
| Galanter et al49 | Not specified | Not specified | 25 per 100 000 alerts |
|
Abbreviations: WPOE: wrong-patient order entry; RAR: retract-and-reorder; PPV: positive predictive value.